The first Position Paper was released in
December 2021: Free & Equal: A reform
agenda for federal discrimination laws. It set
out a reform agenda to modernise our federal
discrimination laws, including by remedying
deficiencies in the current laws, by placing a
greater focus on prevention of discrimination
and by introducing co-regulatory approaches5
that enable governments and businesses in
particular to be better equipped to prevent and/
or deal with discrimination.
But addressing discrimination alone is not
enough to ensure that people’s human rights are
protected.
This second Position Paper sets out reforms
to improve the protection of human rights in
Australia, designed to complement protections
against discrimination and dealing with issues
that discrimination laws are not capable of
addressing. A positive framing of human
rights through a Human Rights Act is needed
to ensure cohesive protections are in place in
Australia, and it would complement the existing
discrimination law framework.
It sets out the Commission’s case for the
introduction of a federal Human Rights Act in
Australia; and an outline of the Commission’s
proposed model.
Indeed, for many years, some have asserted
that alternative ways of protecting human rights
render a Human Rights Act unnecessary in
Australia – but we have not seen a noticeable
improvement in the protection of human rights
in Australia over the past generation. These
alternative measures to a Human Rights Act
have had more than enough time to show if
they can ensure that there is always a fulsome
consideration of human rights in the way we
design, implement and talk about laws and
policies.
34
The Commission’s model has been tested
through consultations with Free & Equal
stakeholders. It draws on comparative
international models, international instruments
and the recommendations of previous inquiries,
including the 2009 Report of the National
Human Rights Consultation Committee, chaired
by Fr Frank Brennan SJ.6 Domestic human rights
legislation in the ACT, Victoria and Queensland
has also provided important guidance and
lessons as to how a Human Rights Act could
operate federally.7 The experience of COVID-19
has tested their particular design and suggested
where improvements could be made.
The Commission’s model takes into account this
experience, Australia’s constitutional and federal
structure, Australia’s international obligations,
Australian values and our legal system.
1.4 Outcomes – the value
of human rights
All human beings are born free and equal
in dignity and rights – Article 1, Universal
Declaration of Human Rights
Australian society prides itself on being built on
values that underpin human rights.
We believe that everyone should be treated
fairly and equally.
We value a free, open and just society, one that
enables us to make our own decisions about
how we live and express ourselves, individually
and in association with others.8
We are opposed to cruelty and the abuse of
power.
Australia is a strong democracy with a robust
electoral and parliamentary system, an
independent judiciary and respect for the rule of
law. For this reason, many people perceive that
their human rights are legally protected when in
fact they are not.