The Commission makes the following
recommendations for improved human rights
protection at the national level in Australia.
1. The Commission recommends that the
Australian Parliament enact a federal Human
Rights Act. The Human Rights Act should
include the elements proposed in this
Position Paper.
2. The Commission recommends the following
measures to improve the parliamentary
scrutiny processes.
• The Commission recommends
amendments to House and Senate
Standing Orders requiring that bills may
not be passed until a final report of the
PJCHR has been tabled in Parliament,
with limited exceptions for urgent
matters. In the event that a Bill proceeds
to enactment by exception, provision
should be included for a later review of the
legislation if the Bill relevantly engaged
human rights.
• Section 7 of the Human Rights
(Parliamentary Scrutiny) Act 2011 (Cth)
should be amended, along the lines
of the power of the UK Human Rights
Committee, to allow it to ‘make special
reports on any human rights issues which
it may think fit to bring to the notice of
Parliament’ (but excluding consideration
of individual cases). The resourcing of the
PJCHR should be increased to enable it to
perform this wider inquiry role.
• Section 9 of the Human Rights
(Parliamentary Scrutiny) Act 2011 (Cth)
should be amended to require statements
of compatibility for all legislative
instruments.
• The range of matters to be addressed in a
statement of compatibility should include
consideration of consultations undertaken
in accordance with the participation duty
proposed in the Commission’s model for a
Human Rights Act.
• Statements of Compatibility should include
consideration of compliance with UNDRIP.
• With the introduction of a Human Rights
Act, the Human Rights (Parliamentary
Scrutiny) Act 2011 (Cth) could be
amended, or an accompanying legislative
instrument drafted to provide greater
clarity on expectations in statements of
compatibility, both in regard to rights
and freedoms set out in the Human
Rights Act and the remaining obligations
under international treaties not expressly
included in the Human Rights Act.
• A public sector human rights education
program be introduced, to provide training
and resources to public servants to
understand and analyse human rights.
• Consideration should be given to having
designated human rights advisers in
Departments.
1.3 Free & Equal inquiry process
The Free and Equal project was announced
on 10 December 2018, Human Rights Day,
and commenced in early 2019. The project
aims to set out the Australian Human Rights
Commission’s proposed reform agenda for
the better protection of human rights at the
national level in Australia. From 2019–2021, the
Commission’s consultative process included:
• the release of an Issues Paper1
• three Discussion Papers, including a
submissions process2
• the Free and Equal national conference on
human rights3
• a visit and conduct of technical
workshops with the United Nations High
Commissioner for Human Rights, and
• a series of roundtables, technical
workshops and stakeholder consultations.4
The project is culminating with the release
of three papers – two position papers on key
reform priorities, and a final report.
FREE AND EQUAL A Human Rights Act for Australia 2022
33