4) Establish an effective, accessible, and constructive
accountability mechanism for the housing system,
including the emergency housing system.
5) Establish an independent advisory and advocacy
group grounded on Te Tiriti o Waitangi.
Government cannot escape its human rights
obligations, including the obligation to deliver
decent emergency housing for those experiencing
homelessness, by asserting that, despite the
failures of the emergency housing system, the
alternative would be worse because people
would have nowhere to stay. We have heard from
people who went back to sleeping in their cars
because they felt safer there than in emergency
accommodation. This speaks to the inadequacy
of the system as it is currently designed and
operating. In a country like Aotearoa New Zealand,
neither homelessness nor a failing emergency
housing system are acceptable and both fall short
of human rights standards.
12
Human Rights Commission
The current emergency housing system is failing
those who are most in need. But it is not beyond
hope or repair. There is progress. For example,
we see positive signs in the introduction of pilot
programmes bringing together a range of different
organisations to work collectively towards change.
Housing and social service providers, community
organisations, hapū and iwi are all doing lifesaving
work, and we have heard many suggestions for
alternative ways of working that could make a
positive difference. Government’s ongoing review
and reset of the emergency housing system offers
an opportunity to take up these new approaches
and initiatives.
The fear of getting it wrong must not stand in
the way of taking opportunities to try something
new. Now, more than ever, we need bold and
courageous thinking about what a decent housing
system would look like to eliminate homelessness.
By working together and with imagination we
can create an environment in which everyone in
Aotearoa New Zealand enjoys the right to a decent
home grounded on Te Tiriti o Waitangi.