214
In March 2015 the IPCA released a review of Police custodial management119 that
identified systemic and organizational deficits that contributed to recurring problems
in Police detention. Specifically, the IPCA noted that discussions with Police and Area
Mental Health Services staff have clearly shown that the problems with the way
Police respond to vulnerable and mentally impaired persons are commonplace. The
report highlighted the absence of appropriate alternatives to Police detention for
dealing with vulnerable people, including those who have not committed an offence,
and the lack of a timely response by Mental Health Services to mentally impaired
persons in Police custody. The IPCA considers that, unless they are violent or pose an
obvious and immediate threat to the safety of others, all practicable steps should be
taken to avoid having mentally impaired people detained in Police cells solely for the
purpose of receiving a mental health assessment.120
215
Police have developed new training packages for both recruit and frontline officers
based on feedback from Mental Health Service User (“MHSU”) groups, and
acknowledged the importance of having MHSU involved in future thinking around
mental health crisis response. Police watch houses with on-site mental health nurses
have also resulted in better monitoring and continuity of care during police custody.
The SPT recommended this practice be applied nationally.
216
The Commission recommends that the Committee urge the Government to take
steps to develop a national strategy and agree a set of actions to ensure the
provision of mental health care in places of detention which includes mechanisms
to ensure the timely and appropriate sharing of individuals’ health information
across Government agencies.
D
Disproportionate representation of people with intellectual or learning disabilities
217
The WGAD heard testimonies when it visited New Zealand that people with
intellectual or learning disabilities are at a particular disadvantage in the criminal
justice system. Police officers, lawyers and officials are inadequately trained in
relation to intellectual and learning disabilities. This has meant that in some cases, an
individual may be questioned by the police without the presence of a lawyer, and is
subsequently convicted and sentenced without or with inadequate legal
representation.
218
It is estimated that 60-70% of people in New Zealand prisons are disabled people.
The disabilities include intellectual or learning disabilities, foetal alcohol syndrome
and poor mental health.
119
120
IPCA, Review of Police Custodial Management, Wellington (March 2015).
Ibid.
Page 58 of 93
Human Rights Commission submission to the Human Rights Committee in relation to New Zealand’s 6th periodic review under the ICCPR