Annual Report 2009-2010
4.185 The report stated that an amount of Rs.20, 000/- as ex-gratia payment was sanctioned
for the next of kin of the two deceased children. It was further stated that Sapandana Rural
Development Society did not maintain it’s Centre in a proper way especially where the food is
cooked for children. The Mandal Education Officer in Papannapet was also suspended for lack
of supervision and the contract of the NGO cancelled.
4.186 The Commission considered the aforementioned report vide its proceedings on 12
February 2009 and called for the postmortem reports and forensic science laboratory reports
in respect of the three deceased persons.
4.187 As per the Forensic Science Laboratory report, no poison was detected in the viscera
of any of the three deceased persons and the Autopsy Surgeon was not able to pin-point any
definite cause for the three deaths that had taken place in the school.
4.188 Upon consideration of all the reports, the Commission observed that the same belied
the claims of the State Government that the three deceased persons had died due to snake bite.
The Commission held that, in any case, it was clear that the two children and one volunteer
had died due to the negligence of the authorities in maintaining the school properly. As action
against the Mandal Education Officer and the Sapandana Rural Development Society had
already been taken, the State was liable to compensate the next of kin of the two children who
died at the tender age of 8 and 9 years. The Commission opined that the ex-gratia payment of
Rs.20,000/- sanctioned by the Government of Andhra Pradesh for the kin of the two deceased
children was highly inadequate. It thus recommended to the Chief Secretary, Government of
Andhra Pradesh vide proceedings dated 7 July 2009 to pay an additional compensation of
Rs. 2,00,000/- each to the next of kin of the deceased two children and submit a compliance
report along with proof of ex-gratia payment as well as additional compensation within six
weeks. The Commission furthermore held that the next of kin of the deceased volunteer Shri
N. Anhaneyulu too was entitled to be compensated by the State and directed to issue a notice
u/s 18 (a) (i) of the PHRA to the Government of Andhra Pradesh as to why suitable monetary
compensation should not be given to the next of kin of the deceased volunteer.
4.189 The State Government subsequently furnished the proof regarding payment of
additional compensation of Rs. 2 lakh each to the next of kin of the two deceased children -Desari Jayamma and L. Vansantha. Besides, it recommended that it would pay a sum of Rs. 2
lakh as monetary relief to the next of kin of the deceased Shri Anjaneyulu.
4.190 As the directions of the Commission were complied with by the State Government, the
case was closed.
32. Suo motu Cognizance of News Aired by ‘Aaj Tak’ Relating to Sexual Exploitation of a Female
Prisoner in Tihar Jail, Delhi (Case No. 1172/30/9/09-10-AR)
4.191 Shri Gaurav Aggarwal, an Advocate, brought to the notice of the Commission a story
carried by ‘Aaj Tak’ news channel on 28 May 2009 wherein it was alleged that a woman prisoner
who was imprisoned in Tihar Jail had become pregnant. Taking cognizance of the ma�er, the
Commission vide its proceedings dated 19 June 2009 called for a report from the Inspector
General of Prisons, Delhi.
NHRC
45