learning, building a learning hub for remote communities, and transcribing
or converting learning modules into accessible formats for learners with
disabilities, such as for those with visual impairment. Another key issue is
the cost of online learning not only to students but also to the teachers as
well. Additional costs further burdened learners with disabilities and their
carers, as well as learners from households below the poverty line, due to
expenses for procuring prepaid cards and paying bills for electricity and
internet connection.
Mental health and multiple burdens of students
165.
Prolonged lockdowns have taken a toll not only on physical health but also
on the mental health and well-being of learners. Such restrictions have
been found to worsen the condition of learners with pre-existing mental
health issues and those living in cramped households and communities.189
Some learners also need to multitask as they attend online classes,
complete modules, and even do household chores and other errands.
These circumstances add up to the mental stress and anxiety that learners
have to endure, to the extent that there are reports of student deaths
related to distance learning.190 Because the students themselves have
experienced the impact of COVID-19 on their mental health, the student
councils of different schools have initiated help desks and hotlines for
students to air their grievances and problems encountered during the
pandemic. Such initiatives are helpful, but attention to the deaths of
students through a formal investigation or inquiry by the government
through DepEd and CHED could have generated interventions and reforms
that can be implemented widely in different schools and academic
institutions to avoid the rise of student deaths.
Vaccination requirement for face-to-face classes
166.
Based on the Human Rights Advisory by the CHR on COVID-19
vaccination, “COVID-19 vaccines should be made affordable and
accessible without discrimination,” especially to the most vulnerable or
marginalized sectors of the population, and “made physically accessible
for marginalized groups and people living in remote areas.”191 The CHR
further notes, “COVID-19 vaccination should not be compulsory and should
only be administered under the conditions of informed consent”192 and
stresses that “At all times, the State should seek to ensure that vaccination
is voluntary.” Acceptability of vaccines, their safety and efficacy,
transparency of the vaccine provider, and the people’s trust in the
government agencies in charge of ensuring the vaccine’s safety are
considerations to be made for issuing a vaccination policy.193 The
vaccination policies issued by CHED and DepEd along with the DOH
contradict these key points as students, teachers, and non-teaching staff
are compelled to get vaccinated to be allowed to enter the school premises
and participate in the limited face-to-face classes. Such policies also
189
supra note 81.
supra note 85.
191
Commission on Human Rights, Human Rights Advisory on COVID-19 Vaccination, CHR (V) 2020-2021, at 5–6 (Jan 26,
2021).
192
CHR, Human Rights Advisory on COVID-19 Vaccination, at 8.
193
Id.
190
60