HUMAN RIGHTS COMMISSION | A FAIR GO FOR A L L ?
Responses to structural discrimination
in the justice system
The criminal justice system broadly consists of police,
This approach is based on constructive engagement with
courts and correctional services. As such, three examples
the community. As such, the New Zealand Police recognise
of initiatives under the umbrella of the justice system
that community relationships are strengthened when police
have been included: Neighbourhood Policing in Counties
units reflect the cultural, ethnic and linguistic diversity
Manukau (Police), Rangatahi and Pasifika Youth Courts
of the communities they serve. Counties Manukau, for
(Courts) and Mäori Focus Units (Correctional Services).
example, aims to have a workforce comprised of six per
Case study 1:
cent Asian police, to reflect the Asian population in the
Neighbourhood Policing in
Counties Manukau
Neighbourhood Policing is a newly-established programme
in New Zealand and the full impacts are not yet known.
Those involved, however, report that it has the potential
community. In a criminal investigation involving a Sikh
family, Indian police staff were able to interact with the
community using shared language and cultural connections
to assist the investigation. Police interactions with the
community are more effective when police can connect
around shared cultural values.
to shift Police relationships with communities and reduce
The Neighbourhood Policing team in Counties Manukau
levels of crime. It also has the potential to address issues
was launched in September 2010, initially with six units of
of structural discrimination within the police force.
one sergeant and up to six constables. By the end of 2011
Neighbourhood Policing changes the values and structure
there were 12 units in Counties Manukau. There are now
that police work is based upon, in order to make policing
33 Neighbourhood Policing teams nationwide. Units within
more effective in reducing crime by placing an emphasis on
the neighbourhood police teams focus on small, primarily
prevention and greater engagement between communities
residential neighbourhoods of approximately 4000 people.
and Police.
In the first phase of the programme the unit visits homes
The programme reflects a shift in national police
to conduct a household survey. The purpose of the survey
strategic planning to an overarching philosophy called
is to gather information about community concerns and
Community Policing.187 Community Policing incorporates
needs and to visibly begin engagement between police and
an emphasis on prevention and proactive work that
the neighbourhood. Common issues raised by community
is reliant on engagement with communities and other
members during the survey collection in Counties Manukau
government agencies. Counties Manukau reflects this
are family violence, drugs, burglary and truancy. The second
prevention philosophy with their new motto, “be safe,
phase of the programme sets up local community boards
feel safe.” Preventative and proactive police-work builds
formed with key representatives of the neighbourhood.
relationships with neighbourhoods and communities over
Together with the community boards, Police participate in
time, working collaboratively to solve problems, while
community-initiated responses to crime.
units simultaneously respond to crime, then follow up with
measures to prevent the same problems happening again.
One sergeant says of the neighbourhood policing team:
The interviewees revealed there was an initial sense of
cynicism within the police force about the Neighbourhood
Policing programme. Some Police felt that “neighbourhood
We’re not expert investigators and we’re not solely
policing isn’t real policing.” When, however, some of
community cops – we’re a bit of a mongrel group
the older, more established and respected sergeants
that can be flexible. The advantage with it is its
volunteered for the programme, staff soon realised the
still relationship-based, so while we’re doing our
impact building collaborative, engaged relationships with
apprehensions and our hard-nosed stuff, we still have
members of the community could have on preventing
a good relationship with both our criminals and our
members of the public.188
39