Australian Human Rights Commission
Submission to UN Committee Against Torture, 17 October 2014
133.
A last resort? was the catalyst for significant changes in arrangements for the
detention of children since 2003. This included that children are no longer
detained in high security immigration detention centres and the Migration Act
now affirms that minors should only be detained as a measure of last resort.114
However, these gains have unravelled since 2011. By July 2013 there were a
record large number of children being detained in closed immigration
detention facilities.
134.
As a result, the Commission commenced a new National Inquiry into Children
in Immigration Detention in February 2014. This is to consider the impact of
immigration detention on the health, well-being and development of children,
and whether laws, policies and practices relating to children in immigration
detention meet Australia’s international human rights obligations.115 The
Inquiry has involved detention centre visits, interviews with families and
children in detention, submissions and the conduct of 5 public hearings. The
report of the Inquiry will be transmitted to the Government in November 2014
and will be released subsequent to this (likely in December 2014).
(b)
Conditions of detention for children
135.
Australia has a specific obligation under article 37(c) of the CRC to ensure that
children in detention are treated with humanity and respect for their inherent
dignity.
136.
The Commission has concerns about the conditions of detention in some
facilities in which children are detained, due to the harsh physical
environments in remote locations (such as at the Leonora Alternative Place of
Detention), and the lack of appropriate recreational spaces, activities and
access to education in facilities such as those on Christmas Island.
137.
Long periods in immigration detention facilities puts children at high risk of
serious mental harm, which may amount to cruel, inhuman or degrading
treatment in breach of the CRC.
(c)
Unaccompanied minors in immigration detention
138.
Australia has obligations to children who arrive in Australia unaccompanied,
especially those who are seeking asylum, to ensure that they receive special
protection and assistance.
139.
An important element of the care of unaccompanied minors is effective
guardianship. In the absence of their parents, the legal guardian of an
unaccompanied minor has the ‘primary responsibility for the upbringing and
development of the child’, and is under an obligation under the CRC to act in
the best interests of the child.
140.
Under Australian law, the Minister is the legal guardian of ‘non-citizen’
unaccompanied minors.
141.
The Commission is concerned that the Minister’s role as guardian of
unaccompanied minors creates a conflict of interest, as the Minister is also
responsible for administering the immigration detention regime under the
38