25. The Indonesian Government, particularly the Minister of Environment and Forestry, Minister of
Energy and Mineral Resources, Head of the National Land Agency (BPN), regional governments,
and district heads, have the authority to lease state lands to corporations and government
bodies through concessions and/or tenurial rights. Many land and natural resources concessions
take the form of logging, mining, plantations, conservation schemes, transmigration and
infrastructure projects located within adat lands and territories. As large-scale investments on
land concessions encroached on the lands of rural communities, land speculation activities
became widespread. As a result many local communities were alienated from their lands with
little benefits from the projects. In summary, there is a long history of grievances and conflicts
related to land and concessions in Indonesia, which continue to pose serious challenges for the
country. Komnas HAM identified increasing recognition that improved land tenure and
protection of the customary rights of the masyarakat adat are critical to the country’s conflict
prevention and inclusive development.
26. There are various processes through which their customary lands and forests are officially
recognized. The first legal process is recognition of the masyarakat adat or masyarakat hukum
adat (indigenous communities). According to several laws and regulations and legal practices,
the legal recognition may be ruled through (1) a general district or provincial regulation for all
indigenous communities within its jurisdiction, (2) a specific district or provincial regulation for a
particular community, (3) an administrative decree, (4) Court decision, and (5) a legal contract.
Moreover, the process for legal recognition of customary lands and forest which are located
within designated forest areas are more complicated. The process become more difficult once
the forest areas already gazette or legalized. Following the legal recognition of the communities,
The District Head should submit a recommendation letter over the status of the lands and
forests to the Ministry of Environment and Forestry. Then the Minister will make the final
decision. Komnas HAM identified several customary lands and forest recognition by various
district governments, however the number of benefitted communities and total designated
areas far too small compare to the overall populations and the land they claim.
27. In addition to contested claims between indigenous peoples and state institutions over natural
resources, there are many more land conflicts affecting other local communities in Indonesia.
Komnas HAM receive more than six thousands complaints annually, and the land issues have
been the highest number among many other complaints.27 Some of the land cases were
reported by indigenous communities, other local communities and retired government officers
(including military personnel and police officers). The types of land issues are ranging from land
grabbing (including customary lands), individual land conflicts to execution of court’s decision
over land cases.
28. Komnas HAM welcomes the initiative of the Parliament to propose the Draft Law on Masyarakat
Hukum Adat. The Draft Law was listed in the Indonesian National Legislation Program 2013 and
remains in the list up to date.28 However, Komnas HAM identified insufficient seriousness of the
27
Komnas HAM, National Inquiry on the Rights of Masyarakat Hukum Adat on Their Territories in the Forest
Zones, 2016, p. 1 – 3, can be accessed at: https://www.komnasham.go.id/files/20160530-inkuiri-nasionalkomisi-nasional-$N60YN.pdf. And the English language Executive Summarty can be accessed at:
https://www.komnasham.go.id/index.php/publikasi/2016/06/01/1/national-inquiry-on-the-right-ofindigenous-peoples-on-their-territories-in-the-forest-zones.html.
28
DPR RI (National Parliament), Lawmakers Push for Draft Law on Masyarakat Hukum Adat to Accommodate
Their
Interests,
2
September
2021,
can
be
accessed
at
https://www.dpr.go.id/berita/detail/id/34421/t/Legislator+Dorong+RUU+MHA+Mengakomodasi+Kepentingan
+Masyarakat+Adat.