Report of the National Inquiry into the Land Rights of Indigenous Peoples
65
4.127 Recognition and protection for native title is also required as part of the constitutional right
to life and livelihood. This takes into account the essential role of land in the economies and
cultural identity of native communities. In determining adequate compensation for deprivation
of native title, the role of land in the livelihood of native communities is a relevant factor.
In addition, damages other than monetary compensation may be necessary in cases where
the deprivation of property also constitutes a deprivation of livelihood, and right to life under
Article 5 of the Constitution.
4.128 Further, Article 8(5)(c) of the Federal Constitution permits the Federal Government to legislate
for the “protection, well-being and advancement” of Orang Asli including “the reservation of
land”. This provision is an overt recognition by the framers of the Constitution of the special
position of Orang Asli in existing constitutional arrangements. As for Sabah and Sarawak,
Article 161 A(5) provides for preferential treatment to natives of Sabah and Sarawak
4.129 Underlying the recognition and protection of native title or customary rights to land is the
fiduciary obligation of the Federal and State Governments towards natives and aboriginal
peoples. To meet the fiduciary obligation, Government officials must not take actions that
are inconsistent with the interests of its beneficiary and may not delegate its discretionary
power to a third party. Furthermore, the fiduciary obligation requires that Government
officials to consult with and obtain the consent of native communities prior to taking action
that may infringe on or extinguish their native title rights.
4.130 Given the interplay between the common law, the legislative provisions, the Federal
Constitution, the existence of indigenous customary practices and the native and aboriginal
conception of property, a morally defensible concept of native customary rights must not
only look to the common law and the statutory provisions, but must fully incorporate the
native perspectives. Where the rights are provided by statute, any inadequacy must be
compensated by reference to the constitutional provisions to give full recognition of the
customary rights to land.
chapter 4_a4.indd 65
7/5/13 6:46 PM