We also convened a series of informal meetings
with ‘integrity agencies’ to discuss human rights
issues arising in the pandemic and oversight
of the Government response. The group
included the Office of the Ombudsman, Office
of the Children’s Commissioner, Independent
Police Complaints Authority, Health and
Disability Commissioner, Office of the Privacy
Commissioner, Chief Censor, Office of the
Auditor General and Inspector of Service Penal
Establishments. The Minister of Justice, Andrew
Little, attended one of the meetings and
answered questions from the group.
In an effort to review the Government’s
performance on human rights and Te Tiriti
in the response to COVID-19, and to help the
Government as it moved forward, we published a
Human Rights and Te Tiriti o Waitangi: COVID-19 and
Alert Level 4 report in April 2020, as the country
went from Alert Level 4 to 3. In it, we reviewed
issues of access to justice, contact tracing,
surveillance and data use, deprivations of liberty,
racism, accessible information, family violence,
older people, women, housing and more. The
report found that one of the striking features of
the Government’s response to COVID-19 was an
inadequate explicit consideration of human rights
and Te Tiriti.10
As the government pushed forward under
urgency with a new COVID-19 Public Health
Response Bill, we expressed deep concerns about
the lack of scrutiny and the rushed process.11
Our criticism of the Bill cautioned that when
sweeping powers are granted through inadequate
processes in times of national emergency there
is a risk of overreach. Mistakes can be made and
later regretted.
10
11
18
Levin testing centre during the COVID-19 pandemic.
Photo courtesy of RNZ.
The Commission’s response was guided by three
essential roles articulated in a letter to New
Zealanders at the beginning of the pandemic:
advising government, connecting community
and holding decision makers accountable. We
are proud of the work we did and the impact we
achieved as a Commission during this time.
https://www.hrc.co.nz/news/human-rights-and-te-tiriti-need-be-part-covid-19-response/
https://www.hrc.co.nz/news/human-rights-commission-deeply-concerned-about-covid-19-public-health-response-bill/
Human Rights Commission Annual Report 2019/20