improvementof the socio-economicorderof society.5° At this stage of development,
every effort is directed towards the enforcementof these primary laws and whenthe
social order soughtto be achievedis attained, “declaratory laws” may be enforced to
restrain people fromdistributing the social order. This kind of laws define crimes and
prescribetheir penalties.5'
Islam recognizes the idea that socio-economic and ecological circumstances
bear a decisive effect upon human behavior.5? Certain conditions and environmental
situations induce and compel manto performanact or adopt a conduct, which is a
sin or a crimein ordinary set of circumstances.*? Criminologists of the Sociological
School point to poverty, unemployment, mass communication media, drunkenness,
gambling and decline in religious observance as the crime-producing factors in all
human societies.54 On the other hand, advocates of the Ecological Theory find that
mostof the delinquents and criminals are foundin the control districts, factory areas
and in bad housing conditions and they are mostly poor.s> Broken family, density of
population and urbanization are also identified as factors that influenced the
commissionof crime.5°
TheIslamic worldview thenis, where these conditions obtainin a society the
State losses the moral authority to enforce declaratory laws that penalize man for
violations of human rights or for subverting the social order, especially where the
penalty prescribed is an extreme measure. In Islam, such a State is called “darul
harb”ora place of warora state in turmoil andit is considered as the culprit in the
disorderthat proceeds with man’s lawlessness brought about,in thefirst place, by the
failure of governmenttoestablish the social order where peoplelivein state of felicity
or darul salaam or land of peace and security. Under a condition of turmoil and
disorder, Islam ordains an indiscriminate exemption from penal liability to sinners
andcriminals. The Qur'an lays downthis juristic thought in this wise:
But whoeveris driven to necessity not desiring , nor exceeding the
limit, no sin shall be upon him.57
In other place, the Prophet Muhammad (MPBUH) says: “There is no
punishmentonthe person compelled.”58
Indeed, in the early days of Islam, there were instances when penalty was not
enforced on transgressors. The 2"! Caliph of Islam OmarAl-Khattab suspended the
enforcementof the penalty on theft during a period of famine under the impression
that people might be compelled to steal by hunger.5? The Caliph, in an incident of
theft, ordered the employer of some young menwhostole and slaughtered the shecamelofanotherfor food to quench their hunger, to pay double theprice of the camel
for starving them by not paying their wages.®° Poverty, in Islam is an exempting
°° MuhammadTahir-ul-Qadri, “Islam and Criminality.” 1988: Lahore, p. 139
* Ibid
* Ibid., p. 138
*Ibid.
**H. Jones, “Crime and the Penal System,” p. 53. In Muhammad Tahir-ul-Qadri, ibid., p. 61
°E.M. Thrasher, “The Gang,” 1937; C.R. Shaw and H.D. Mckay,”Juvenile Delinquency and Urban
Area.” 1942. In Muhammad Tahir-ul-Qadri, ibid., p.63
°° Herman Mannheim,“Comparative Criminology,” Vol Il, p. 532. In Muhammad Tahir-ul-Qadri, ibid.,
pp. 64-65,
°7 Qur'an 5:3
°® Qur’an 6:120
°° Muhammad Tahir-ul-Qadri, ibid., p. 140
* Ibid.
22