CHAPTER 2
DOMESTIC LEGAL FRAMEWORKS AND
INTERNATIONAL HUMAN RIGHTS
FRAMEWORKS
DOMESTIC LEGAL FRAMEWORKS
29.
The design of laws, policies and practices of most states are often based
on heteronormativity41. There are many issues that have been raised by
transgender groups which relates to violation of human rights, including,
among others, arbitrary and violent arrests by the enforcement authorities
and denial of employment due to their gender identity and gender expression.
However, in the eyes of the state and partly of society, the discrimination is
insignificant since transgender persons are not recognised as a legitimate part
of the society due the prevalence of heteronormativity. Moreover, the existing
discriminatory laws and policies further support the act of the state to prosecute
the transgender person. They are widely criticized for their experience42 and
accused of being morally wrong in practicing unacceptable behaviour which
are against the religious and cultural norms. Hence, this alienation could affect
or limit their access to fundamental rights.
30.
In this chapter, observations will be made on several domestic legal frameworks
followed by related international human rights framework.
The Federal Constitution of Malaysia
31.
The Human Rights Commission Act 1999 provides the definition of “human
rights” referring to the fundamental liberties as enshrined in Part II of the
Federal Constitution43 and due regard shall be had to the Universal Declaration
of Human Rights 1948 to the extent that it is not inconsistent with the Federal
Constitution44. Therefore, human rights are protected as intended by the
Federal Constitution which could be seen in the Article 5 – 13 touching on
liberty of the person, prohibition of slavery and forced labour, protection
against retrospective criminal laws and repeated trials, equality, prohibition
of banishment and freedom of movement, freedom of speech, assembly and
association, rights in respect of education and rights to property respectively.
32.
The arguments on the rights of transgender is narrated by the above-mentioned
rights especially Article 5 of the Federal Constitution which provides that “no
person shall be deprived of his life or personal liberty in accordance with law”.
41 http://www.yourdictionary.com/heteronormativity accessed on 16 November 2017, heteronormativity
means: is the view that all human beings are either male or female, both in sex and in gender, and that
sexual and romantic thoughts and relations are normal only when between people of different sexes.
42 Same sex intercourse, cross dressing and undergone for gender re-assignment surgeries
43 Section 2 of Human Rights Commission Act 1999
44 Section 4 (4) of Human Rights Commission Act 1999
18
| Report On Transgender Persons In KL And Selangor