Ⅰ. Guaranteeing the Fundamental Human Freedoms: 2. Freedom of Expression
C) Democracy and Freedom of Expression
Free expression and the exchange of conscience and ideology is the most
important factor of today’s democracy. Meaning, the freedom of expression is an
indispensible prerequisite of democracy, and a country that does not guarantee
freedom of expression is not considered a democratic country.
Major international human rights organizations, including UNHRC, emphasizes
the guarantee of freedom of expression stipulated in Article 19 of the ICCPR, and
recommends the abolition of criminal penalty for contempt. Contempt that
penalizes opinions and emotions, which cannot be verified, in itself is against the
UN ICCPR.
In Korean society today, asserting the decriminalization of contempt is not easy,
as there are cases of suicides by entertainers and ordinary people due to malicious
and contemptuous comments online. Contempt clearly has elements of invading
another’s honor, even if they are opinions or an expression of emotions.
Contemptuous expressions have the function of making public his/her own
opinions for not having any other countermeasures after being damaged due to the
governmental authority, money or social influence beyond his/her own. Therefore,
even if such expressions may be vulgar, they correspond to the degree of his/her
emotions, and restricting an excessive expression is similar to censoring people
sharing their feelings.46) If fully abolishing contempt is difficult, then we must
consider not overtly restricting the expression of opinions and emotions towards
the president, politicians and high officials.
46) Cohen v. California, 403 US 15, 1971: the government cannot criminalize the display of profane words in public
places
53