Ⅰ. Guaranteeing the Fundamental Human Freedoms: 1. Right to Life and Personal Liberty
B. Main Topics
1) Discussions on the Abolition of the Death Penalty
A) Korea Awaits the Third Constitutional Appeal on the Death Penalty
According to Amnesty International, 144 countries are listed as abolitionist7)
including 28 abolitionist de facto, and 55 countries are listed as retentionist. South
Korea is classified as abolitionist de facto as the death penalty has not been
executed for over 20 years since 1997. According to the ‘2021 Supreme Court
Yearbook’ published by the National Court Administration, no criminal cases
resulted in death sentences in 2020. In addition, the ‘Monthly Court Statistics’ from
the official website of the Supreme Court of Korea points out that no death
sentence was imposed both in the High Court and Supreme Court in 2021. As of
2020, 56 prisoners are on death row.8)
The appellate court upheld the life imprisonment sentence of an offender
convicted of murdering three women from Nowon district in March 2021. The
court states, ‘while the case calls for the death penalty,’ this court has no other
option than to impose a life term in prison – South Korea is an abolitionist in
practice in which capital punishment no longer has a practical effect as a punitive
measure in the country.“ The court also insisted that the life sentence should be
imposed without parole. This demonstrates that the judiciary clearly recognizes
South Korea to be abolitionist de facto.
The Constitutional Court upheld the death penalty in its rulings on Nov. 28, 1996
(constitutionality of Article 250 of the Criminal Act, Case No. 1995HunBa1) and on
Feb. 25, 2010 (constitutionality of Article 41, etc. of the Criminal Act, Case No.
7) According to Amnesty International, the abolitionist in practice refers to the countries which retain the death
penalty for ordinary crimes but they have not executed anyone during the past 10 years and are believed to have
a policy or established practice of not carrying out executions.
8) MOJ, “2021 Correctional Services Statistics Yearbook,” July 2021.
15