analytical approaches.29 In this respect, the right to education epitomises the indivisibility and
interdependence of all human rights.30 It is, therefore, important to study the link between the
right to education and other human rights.
The exercise of the right to education enables the individual to experience the benefit of other
rights, including both economic, social and cultural rights and civil and political rights. The
right to education has a particularly close connection with the right to work, the right to health
and the right to freedom of expression and information.31 In regard to the right to work, the
provision of various levels of formal education as well as vocational training allows States to
compete in the global market and pursue economic growth. However, many human rights
bodies and experts continue to emphasise that the benefits of education should not be
measured in mere economic terms and that a human rights based approach to education is
essential.
Finally, since human rights do not exist in a vacuum, national plans of action for the
implementation of each right should be interrelated. When steps towards the realisation of the
right to education may have an unintended negative impact on the enjoyment of other rights,
mitigating measures will be required. For example, if a child is working to contribute to his
or her family’s income in order to buy food, forcing the same child to go to school might lead
to hunger in his or her family.
Thus, in circumstances like this, States have adopted
programmes to provide food for children in schools and also provide financial assistance to
their families. Such a response ensures that neither the right to education nor the right to food
is compromised.
Components of the right to education
A clearly defined set of elements and components of the right to education can be garnered
from international human rights law.
The right to education comprises four levels of
education: primary or elementary education; secondary education, including technical and
vocational education; higher or tertiary education; and basic or fundamental education.32
29
Report of the Special Rapporteur on the right to education E/CN.4/2003/9 21 January 2003 at
para 29.
30
CESCR General Comment No. 11: Plans of action for primary education E/C.12/1999/4 10 May
1999 at para 2.
31
Some authors categorise the right to education as an “empowerment right” because the exercise of
the right to education “enables a person to experience the benefit of other rights”: see Coomans “In
Search of the Core Content of the Right to Education” in Chapman and Russel (eds) Core Obligations:
Building a Framework for Economic, Social and Cultural Rights (2002) 217 at 219.
32
Each of these levels of education will be discussed in more detail under term of reference (iv).
42