99
This rift in the judiciary led to the development of the judiciary in the West Bank
which was not parallel to the developments taking place in the Gaza Strip.107
The political divide has also disrupted the Legislative Council’s activities,
particularly with regard to the amendment of laws and regulations for meeting
the urgent need for judicial promotion. This is especially so as pragmatic
application proved to be necessary for the amendment of some judicial texts due
to their inconformity with the status quo in the West Bank, as some of these
texts have also impeded the promotion of the judicial system, and the right to
have access to justice.
The Civil and Commercial Procedure Law, particularly the texts on judicial
notifications, where implementation was still limited and slow due to shortage in
technological means as well as in the number of summons servers, required
urgent amendment.
3‐ Encroachment of Military Jurisdiction on Civil Jurisdiction
Paragraph (2) of Article (101) of the Palestinian Basic Law states that “Military
courts shall be established by special laws. Such courts may not have any
jurisdiction beyond military affairs”.
However, on the ground the situation is completely different. ICHR documented
the investigation and arrest of civilians by Security Services at the request of the
Military Judiciary, and in violation of the above‐mentioned provisions, thus
depriving civilians from their right to be presented before a natural judge (i.e.,
regular judiciary).
As the detention of civilians has been discussed in detail in Chapter 2 of this part,
what concerns us here is the impact of such measures on fair and legal
procedures, particularly with regard to the right to access justice and a fair trial,
and particularly since such measures are an encroachment on the jurisdiction of
the civil judiciary. They are also an obstacle which impedes the efforts of the
regular judiciary to enforce the rule of law.
107
For more about the formation of the Higher Judicial Council (the Supreme Council of Justice) in the
Gaza Strip and ICHR’s position towards its formation, please see previous annual reports.
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents