Executive Summary
Since its establishment in 2000, Human Rights Commission of Malaysia (the
Commission) has received numbers of complaints concerning human rights violations
including deaths in the lock-ups under Royal Malaysia Force (PDRM) custody. Thus,
in 2014, the Commission had conducted a research to identify the factors which
influence the deaths in police custody. According to the Commission, right to life
should be respected as it is enshrined in Article 5 of the Federal Constitution and
should not be disregarded by any parties especially among the enforcing bodies. This
matter is also highlighted at international level, for example in Article 3 of the Universal
Declaration of Human Rights (UDHR).
Based on statistics provided by PDRM, the no. of deaths in police custody from 2000
to 2014 is 255 with the average no. of 17 annual cases within these 15 years period.
This scenario indicates grave conflicts which cause dissatisfaction among the public.
Frequent occurrence of the cases and various complaints received from the deceased
family members as well as non-governmental organizations (NGO) show the existence
of a systemic problem on managing the detainees in the lock-ups. At the same time,
this problem has tarnished PDRM credibility in the eye of the community.
Therefore, the Commission had proposed an initiative to examine the factors which
contribute the deaths in custody. Due to existing constraints, the Commission was not
able to perform a thorough investigation to every reported case. Instead, the
Commission had addressed the approach of analyzing the pattern and underlying
factors of the death so that this critical violation of human rights can be diminished
consistently in the future.
The Commission had visited PDRM lock-ups, police stations and interviewed the
detainees, PDRM officers and personnel. The Commission had also observed the
working surroundings especially for Investigation Officers (IO) and Assistant
Investigation Officers (AIO) as well as the facilities provided to fulfill their duties.
As a result of the thematic study, the Commission successfully published this report
which generally consists of 11 chapters.