Australian Human Rights Commission
Australia and the International Convention on the Elimination of All Forms of Racial
Discrimination (ICERD), Shadow report to the CERD Committee – 8 July 2010
6.12
Native Title (ICERD Articles 2, 5 and Declaration Articles
3,10,11,20,25,26, 27,28,29,32)
65.
While the Commission welcomes the Government’s commitment to improving
the operation of the native title system, recent legislative reforms do not
overcome the system’s limitations. 60 For example, Indigenous peoples bear
the burden of demonstrating continuity, from sovereignty to the present:
66.
•
of their society
•
in the observance of traditional laws and customs and
•
in the content of those laws and customs, to prove native title. This is
despite the impact of colonisation. 61
The Committee expressed several concerns about the native title system in
its 2005 Concluding Observations on Australia. 62 The Government’s Report
does not sufficiently address the Committee’s concerns that:
•
the 1998 amendments to the Native Title Act 1993 (Cth) rolled back
protection of native title, and provide legal certainty for Government and
third parties at the expense of native title
•
the burden of proof for Indigenous peoples in Australia continues to be a
significant barrier to achieving a determination that native title exists.
Recommendation 23: That the Australian Government take immediate steps to
review the native title system and to implement measures to address the
above concerns. Such measures should include amendments to the Native
Title Act to provide for presumptions in favour of native title claimants,
including a presumption of continuity in the acknowledgement and
observance of traditional law and custom and of the relevant society. 63
6.13
Homelands (ICERD Article 5 and Declaration Articles
3,11,12,20,21)
67.
Homelands are located on Aboriginal ancestral lands with cultural and
spiritual significance to the Aboriginal people who live there. Homelands
provide a healthy alternative living environment for Aboriginal people who
want to avoid some of the problems that can be associated with living in
larger regional centres. 64 Due to the relatively small populations of
Homelands and their dispersal over large unpopulated regions homeland
populations have been under-resourced and underfunded for many years.
68.
Current government policy prioritises service delivery to 15-20 selected
towns across the NT. This limits the delivery of services in homeland
communities to existing homelands. No funding is being provided to construct
housing on homelands, and most services are being made available through
hub towns. 65 This could result in homeland communities being unable to
access adequate housing, water, sanitation, power, education, and health
21