Also largely reflecting the poor prospects for work and livelihoods in the country is
how there are very few cases of foreigners arrested for violations of working without
permits or engaging in business without proper permits or visas. The BI records only 132
arrests in the two-and-a-half years from 2007 until mid-2009, the overwhekningly number
of whom were Chinese (99 arrests) and Koreans (18).
Nonetheless it is still possible that these are significantly underestimated. To some
degree the country's archipelagic nature and lack of land borders with any of its
neighbours in Southeast Asia acts as a natural barrier that makes illicit movements more
difficult. Yet the southern part of the country is still relatively accessible to determined
migrants from Indonesia and Malaysia. The waiving of entry visa requirements for
ASEAN nationalities also means that alien registration figures would be unable to
account for ASEAN country nationals who entered the Philippines as tourists, for
instance, and then subsequently sought employment and have not been found out by the
BI.
The Indonesian embassy in Manila for instance estimates around 20,000-25,000
Indonesians in the country of which around'20,000 are undocumented yet have been
living in Mindanao for some four decades now. It is estimated that some 85%o of these are
unskilled and only 15% skilled. Even if there is already a third generation of children
bonL raised, living and working in the country they still do not consider themselves
Filipino. The embassy of Laos reports only around 10 of their citizens in the country
rnostly students in Metro Manila. There are also an undetermined number of
undocumented Malaysian nationals also in Mindanao. This is the only information
available from attempted interviews with ASEAN country embassies in Manila.
II. Migration and Development
Migration and remittances have become very significant for many economies and
been hailed as offering new opportunities for economic development. Migration is
certainly a right for people in their pursuit of decent work and livelihoods for themselves
and their families. In particular much attention has been given to how remittances
increase incomes of receiving households and how they are an increasingly large part of
financial flows to developing countries. The benefits of migration and remittances to
households and to economies as a whole are widely presumed - however their real
contribution to real domestic development is much more qualified if they are assessed in
their broader social, economic and political context. Indeed there is reason to be sceptical
of any economic policy thrust that overly relies on these as a primary means to advance
economic development.
t3