Human Rights And Statelessness
I N P E N I N S U L AR M AL AYS I A
1.2 Definition of statelessness and categories of interest
In this study, we refer to stateless populations in Peninsular Malaysia
in two contexts, in situ statelessness in a non-migratory context, and
stateless persons with a migratory context. In situ statelessness involves
stateless people in a non-migratory context who find themselves stateless
in their own country of birth. A working definition for in situ statelessness
is stateless persons “who are in their ‘own country’, meaning a country
with which they have significant and stable ties through birth, long term
residence etc.” (Gyulai, 2012). These are persons who were born and have
lived their entire lives in the country but are unable to acquire nationality
because they may lack the necessary documentation. Statelessness in
situ is often the result of the framing and implementation of nationality
laws (UNHCR, 2014). We refer to seven of the stateless populations
as statelessness in situ: persons with long-standing residence since
pre-independence and their descendants, abandoned children born in
Malaysia, adopted children in Malaysia, children of ‘mixed’ marriages or
cases where children were born out of wedlock, children born outside of
Malaysia to Malaysian mothers and non-Malaysian fathers, indigenous
persons, and undocumented persons. These in situ stateless persons can
be considered as ‘administratively’ stateless persons as they are entitled
to legal recognition in the country but are unable to access citizenship
due to administrative, financial, legal, or discriminatory barriers. A person
who qualifies for citizenship but has not acquired citizenship is considered
as stateless regardless of their past or future claims and qualifications
to citizenship.
On the other hand, stateless persons in a migratory context are persons
who have a migratory background, such as refugees or migrants who
have no genuine and effective links with the country they live in, and so
do not automatically qualify for Malaysian citizenship. Some stateless
refugees who have lived in Malaysia for a long period of time may qualify
for citizenship but they can only apply for citizenship by naturalisation or
registration, and must meet the requirements to establish their genuine
and effective link to Malaysia (Liew, 2019).
6