Australian Human Rights Commission
Respect at Uni Interim Report
December 2024
racist. Poor student feedback can jeopardise casual employment or hinder
career progression. The Commission heard that some academics adjust their
teaching of these more challenging topics to avoid negative repercussions. This,
in turn, leads to a decline in racial literacy within universities, as academics who
can teach these subjects become concerned about the impact on their careers
and are less willing to address ‘difficult knowledge’ such as colonisation and
white privilege.
The Indigenous Law and Justice Hub also described how these dynamics can add
to the cultural and colonial load for First Nations academics:
The ‘minority status’ of Indigenous Peoples in the field of legal education
and the cultural divide between non-Indigenous students and Indigenous
educators … see students emotionally reacting to having their own world
view challenged and add to the already significant colonial load for
educators. 69
In Commission consultations, First Nations academics provided an example of a
non-Indigenous student writing an entire essay about their frustrations about
needing to learn about Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander health, full of
discriminatory language. Staff ‘escalated [the matter] under academic
misconduct but because the student didn’t threaten anyone specifically, there
was nothing done about the case.’ 70
In Commission consultations, First Nations academics described the lack of
cultural safety directly impacting their career decisions. One academic described
their teaching experience as ‘terribly unsafe’ and led to moving away from
teaching roles to pure research roles. The Commission heard that First Nations
academics feel ‘invisible’, that course coordinators took credit for their work,
especially related to cultural knowledge. The additional cultural load of
supporting First Nations students and colleagues can also create negative
impacts:
We’ve got to work with the students who are dealing with [racism] and our
colleagues who are perpetrating colonial violence onto students. We aren’t
rewarded for that. In fact, we are actually being punished for the work we
need to do to keep students safe. 71
Some academics felt that other faculty members were less likely to collaborate
with them if they were known for their strong views. Again, this could result in
reduced research and promotion opportunities. Academics described being
punished for being outspoken about race issues, ranging from reprimands to
45