Digital Rights Alliance
Protecting Human Rights from Military Technologies, 30 November 2023
6
Question 6
43. Although there are many strategies to protect the right to equality and nondiscrimination in the design and deployment of NTMD, a principal safeguard
should be the inclusion of an ‘informed human in the loop’. This is especially
important where NTMD utilises data sets and algorithms. There should always
be an individual who has oversight of the design, deployment and use of
NTMD.
44. While a human in the loop may improve accountability and fairness, they must
be educated on the risks of discrimination in NTMD.28 Individuals who have
oversight of NTMD (especially NTMD that make decisions or utilise AI) need
significant training on the flaws of data sets, algorithms and AI tools. They must
also be encouraged to scrutinise AI-outcomes, especially where such outcomes
can result in the deprivation of life.
45. However an ‘informed human in the loop’ in isolation is insufficient, there must
be additional safeguards in place, and consideration given to whether the
specific functions of a NTMD should even be automated.29
7
Question 17
7.1
Australian Human Rights Commission
46. On 07 June 2023, Human Rights Commissioner, Lorraine Finlay, participated in
RightsCon Costa Rica. Commissioner Finlay delivered the speech ‘Stopping
Killer Robots – Prohibiting the use of Lethal Autonomous Weapon Systems’. The
speech called for urgent legislation to effectively regulate LAWS and limit their
misuse. The speech summarised the key issues around LAWS, including
technical inaccuracies of FRT and its possible implications in rising domestic
terrorism and broader arms races. The Commission continues to advocate for
LAWS regulation.
47. The Australian Human Rights Commission has also examined the use of
neurotechnologies in military spheres as part of its upcoming Background
Report on Neurotechnology and Human Rights.
48. The Australian Human Rights Commission has prepared its own submission to
this inquiry.
7.2
Danish Institute of Human Rights
49. The DIHR has been working on the broader impact of new technologies on
digital and human rights. DIHR is the Chair of the NHRIs Alliance for Digital
9