5
Criminal justice system
Australian Human Rights Commission
Report title October 2022
Relevant provisions of the CAT: Articles 2, 11 and 16.
5.1
First Nations Peoples
62. First Nations peoples continue to be significantly overrepresented in prisons
in Australia. Reasons for over-incarceration include both legal and policy
factors, and socio-economic factors such as cultural displacement, trauma
and grief, alcohol and other drug misuse, cognitive disabilities and poor
health and living conditions.60 Institutional racism, and a ‘legacy of
dispossession, marginalisation and exclusion have created conditions in
which Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander peoples experience serious and
multiple forms’ of disadvantage and inequality.61 In order to reach a solution
to over-incarceration, it is necessary to attend to the root causes of First
Nations inequality in a comprehensive manner, which involves addressing
factors both within, and beyond, the justice system.
63. Although First Nations peoples make up 3.2% of the total population,62 they
constitute 30% of the prison population.63 First Nations women are the
fastest growing prisoner population – and they are 19 times more likely than
non-Indigenous women to be in prison.64 Almost half (49%) of the young
people in juvenile detention on an average day in 2020–21 were First
Nations children and young people.65
64. Due to the over-representation of First Nations peoples in the criminal
justice system, First Nations peoples are more likely to die in police or prison
custody compared to the general (non-prison) population.66 In the years
since the landmark report of the Royal Commission into Indigenous Deaths
in Custody in 1991, which first highlighted the extent of this issue, there
have been a further 517 deaths in custody that have been identified as First
Nations peoples.67 Many of these deaths were found in inquests to be
preventable.
65. The Commission welcomes the Partnership Agreement in 2019 between the
Coalition Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander Peak Organisations and all
Australian Governments (Partnership Agreement).68 Parties to the
Partnership Agreement have committed to reducing the rate of First Nations
adults held in incarceration by at least 15% by 2031 and reducing the rate of
First Nations children (10–17 years) in detention by at least 30% by 2031. The
Commission also welcomes funding provided by the Australian Government
to meet these justice targets,69 and emphasises the importance of
15