Ms. Nurul Izzah agreed with this stance and stated that the APPGM together with
the Prison Departments and other stakeholders had conducted a Zoom Meeting
with a stakeholder from Wales to address the bottle neck to be addressed from
the beginning of the process. She believes that this is a great way for Malaysia to
find suitable stakeholders, and to establish a working committee to looking at the
impact as it helps everyone in doing their job in an efficient and cost saving
manner. It involves monetary sense. Hence, we hope to start the first face after
the bottleneck being addressed in Malaysia.
Attorney Katherine C. said that we should look at what is the case with the
Philippines justice system, the ability of law enforcement.
Mr. Liew Chin Tong mentioned that police reform is needed to strengthen criminal
investigations in line with the recommendations in the Report of the Royal
Commission to enhance the Operation and Management of the Royal Malaysian
Police83 The Police force in Malaysia had been centralized and very political since
the early 1950s to combat communism under the British colonial administration.
We should look at how to improve criminal investigations and to strengthen them
compared to other political functions of the police.
II. Question for MP YB Nurul Izzah by Mr. Dines from FMT. Is there any alternative
action that MPs concerned with prison reform can take if their private member’s
bills do not go through?
Ms. Nurul Izzah stated that to join forces with the APGMM, but she also looks
forward to the working committee of prison reform to give a clear-cut agenda like
for example, the Ministry of Welfare that is concerned with the welfare of prison
officers. We need parliamentary reform to enable private bills and to enable
passing of the said bills. Because again when we talk about prison reform, the
pandemic has raised the awareness with various stakeholders. APPGM and the
committee still needs to derive the legitimacy from the Ministry. We do need to
appreciate the reality and act pragmatically. She also highlighted the important
role of the media fraternity in providing coverage on this issue.
III. Ms. Vignes, Prison Department, we should not forget prison officers in prisons.
When there are complaints about prison staffs, of course lawsuit action will be
taken against prison officers. No efforts were made to clear the name of prison
officers or the prison department. The impact of this is that it would hinder
people from joining the prison department for being stigmatised with these
complaints.
Mr. Liew Chin Ting responded that parliamentarians pay attention to the morale
and welfare of prison officers. The parliamentarian system does not favour a
bipartisan system. As far as prison reform is concerned, we need bilateral
83
The report was prepared by Tun Mohammed Dzaiddin Bin Haji Abdullah, Chairman of the Royal Commission
to Enhance the Operation and Management of the Royal Malaysian Police in 2005
65