Office of the Ombudsman, Samoa‘s National Human Rights Institution
Submission to the Committee on the Rights of the Child – September 2015
Recommendation 26: That the Samoan Government develop systematic
and regular educational and vocational programs for juvenile detainees
with the aim of rehabilitating juvenile detainees and successfully
integrating them back into society.
11.5
Fa’asamoa, juvenile justice and other identified issues
98.
The fa‘asamoa has long played an important role in detention facilities in
Samoa and it is important to detail how it still contributes to the safety and
security of juveniles held within Oloamanu and Tafaigata.
99.
In each facility, the Corrections Management selects a matai (chief) for each
cell based on maturity and leadership skills of the prisoner. In Oloamanu, one
matai is based there permanently (taken from Tafaigata). The matai is seen as
a leader and mentor to prisoners who assist with resolving any minor
issues/disputes among the prisoners and raises any concerns they might have
with facility staff and vice versa. They also teach and mentor juveniles in the
fa’asamoa, teaching them about feavaa‘i (mutual respect), alofa (love) and
fepuipuia‘i (mutual protection). The social framework that this provides juvenile
detainees undoubtedly helps with rehabilitation, lowers rates of recidivism and
improves safety and security within the facilities. The NHRI supports the
integration of fa’asamoa and detention centre management and welcomes the
Commissioner of Prisons and Corrections Services recent stated commitment
to ensuring its retention and application.
100.
The NHRI is concerned about the use of the matai system to strengthen the
safety and security within juvenile detention – that it could lead to prisoners
not being able to make a complaint through the formal channels in accordance
with Rule 75 of the Havana Rules. The NHRI welcomes the introduction of a
formal complaints mechanism to coexist alongside the matai system,
implemented shortly before the inspection of Oloamanu Juvenile Centre. The
NHRI will continue to monitor the effectiveness of this dual system through its
inspections.
101.
The NHRI is compelled to highlight a concerning incident which occurred in
October 2014. It was reported in the media that a 3 year old child had been
locked up inside a police custody cell alongside his father, who had been
arrested for motoring offences.117 This is in contravention of Article 37 (b) of
Convention which clearly states that no child shall be deprived of their liberty
unlawfully or arbitrarily.
102.
The NHRI undertook an investigation into the circumstances of the case and
produced a report highlighting this as a breach of Article 37 (b).118 The report
called for the demotion of the culpable officers and a review of the culture
within the Police force which contributed to the unlawful detention. These
117
Samoa Observer ‗Three year old locked up in police cell‘, 2 October 2014 at
http://www.samoaobserver.ws/home/headlines/11776-three-year-old-locked-up-in-police-cell
[accessed 10 September 2015].
118
Report can be found at http://www.samoaobserver.ws/other/legal/11911-father-police-failed-boy32