7.6 Specialist health care
services and external
appointments
Allied health and specialist appointments are
managed by a combination of regular onsite
visits and external appointments. A visiting
physiotherapist attends the centre weekly, a
sonographer fortnightly, and an optometrist
quarterly. The dental service is also provided by a
visiting local dentist. IHMS advised the Commission
that they were sourcing a visiting podiatrist. Services
for people requiring specialist or intensive treatment
are also delivered through arrangements with
hospitals in Perth and elsewhere.
In relation to attending external medical
appointments, several people described being
required to wear handcuffs when attending some
appointments but not for others. The inconsistency
of this practice and its impacts have already
been raised in several of the Commission’s past
inspections.80 Serco told the Commission that
restraints are not necessarily used for every transfer
or movement and that a choice was often made
between mechanical restraints or enhanced escort,
which involves more staff.
One of the written submissions received by the
Commission noted that ‘the use of handcuffs
and other restraints discourages attendance at
offsite medical and mental health appointments,
potentially exacerbating existing health conditions
and delaying diagnosis of others. It also further
harms the mental health of detainees, many of
whom are already suffering the adverse effects of
prolonged detention’.
While the Commission recognises that there may be
a legitimate need to use physical restraints in certain
circumstances, it is also important to acknowledge
that the use of restraints may risk exacerbating
some medical conditions (particularly mental health
issues) and is particularly problematic with respect
to individuals who have previously been victims of
torture and trauma.
Many people at YHIDC described the ordeal of
being handcuffed as confronting and one person
described the experience as extremely distressing
due to his previous trauma experience, stating he
would become very unwell during the journey as
a result.
Yongah Hill Immigration Detention Centre Inspection Report • 2024 • 41