3 | The Child Rights Impact Assessment tool
Stage 5: Result and recommendations
14. Summarise how this assessment demonstrates why the proposed policy/
legislation is in the best interests of children.
15. Are there any further changes that need to be made to the policy/legislation to
ensure children’s rights are not negatively impacted?
In Stage 5, the assessor is required to draw
conclusions and make recommendations to
either advance or amend the policy/legislation
based on the information collected in Stages 1
to 4. It asks the assessor to make an informed
judgement as to whether a child’s best interests
are supported by the policy/legislation. The CRC
does not explicitly define a child’s best interests.
However, its meaning can be derived from the
content in other CRC Articles, including:
24 |
•
In the case of actions and decisions
affecting an individual child, it is the best
interests of that individual child which must
be taken into account
•
It is in a child’s best interest to enjoy the
rights and freedoms set out in the CRC. For
example, it is in children’s best interests to
develop respect for human rights and for
other cultures (Article 29.1(b) and (c)). It is
in a child’s best interest to maintain contact
with both parents in most circumstances
(Article 9.3)
•
It is in the best interests of Indigenous
children to be raised in their Indigenous
community (Articles 5, 8.2, and 30)
•
A child capable of forming a view on their
best interests must be able to give it freely
and it must be taken into account (Article
12)
•
Parents have primary decision-making
responsibility on behalf of their children
(Articles 5 and 18.1) but, if they fail to make
children’s best interests a basic concern,
the State may intervene to protect those
interests (Article 9.1).27