The aim of this project was to develop a CRIA
tool that could be used by government decisionmakers to assess the direct and indirect impact
of legislation and policy on children’s rights and
ensure that children’s voices, experiences, and
priorities are built into government decisions that
will impact on their lives.
The tool was to be adaptable to local contexts
and to the needs of different jurisdictions,
and able to be used in all situations, including
emergency situations. The tool was not intended
to replace the existing jurisdictional CRIA tools
or assessment mechanisms, but to enable each
jurisdiction to either adopt the national CRIA tool
in whole or merge aspects of it into their existing
tools.
By developing the tool, the National Children’s
Commissioner seeks to promote active
consideration by decision-makers of the
following:15
•
the aim(s) of the law, policy, or practice for
children
•
whether children and their representative
organisations have been involved in the
development of the law, policy, or practice
•
whether particular groups of children will
be affected
•
what human rights are impacted and
whether that impact can be assessed
•
where there is negative impact, whether
that impact can be mitigated or negated in
the situation.
The tool is designed to be used at the
development stage of policy/legislation in order
to mitigate any potential risks and challenges
impacting the rights and wellbeing of children
and strengthen potential positive impacts.
However, it should be noted that conducting
a CRIA may require seeking and considering
information at various stages of the policy or law
development process.
Completed CRIAs may also act as an evidence
base for future decision-making, or as an
evaluation mechanism (a CRIE), as described in
section 2.
3.1 Design and development
of the tool
A design thinking approach was used to develop
the tool. Design thinking is a ‘systematic
approach to problem solving’.16 The problem
to be solved for this project was ‘how might we
develop a tool that supports policy-makers and
legislators in assessing the impacts of policies or
legislation that they develop on children’s rights
and wellbeing?’.
Interviews were conducted with a variety of
government and non-government stakeholders
and potential users of the tool. The Victorian
Commission for Children and Young People also
sought and provided feedback from members of
their youth advisory group. Shared themes from
this engagement included:
•
strong support for a CRIA tool as a concept
and acknowledgement that children are
seldom engaged with as stakeholders on
policy/legislation
•
policy is usually developed with little time
and few resources
•
most policy-makers have limited
knowledge of children and their needs
Safeguarding Children: Using a child rights impact assessment to improve our laws and policies | 15