The Independent Commission for Human Rights (ICHR) | Shadow report
subjected to torture so that they can return to normal life and reintegrate into
society. Further, the report does not indicate government preparations for the
rehabilitation process, including cadres, centres, and services provided by the
State.
• In relation to persons held in psychiatric care centres
The report refers to a number of community institutions, which provide day
care to persons with mental and/or psychosocial disabilities. There is one
psychiatric hospital in the Bethlehem governorate. However, the report does
not provide adequate data on persons with psychosocial impairments in the
West Bank and Gaza Strip. In particular, there is no mention of the number of
inmates at the Bethlehem hospital, number of MoH psychiatric clinics, number
of patients who receive electroconvulsive therapy, and how relevant protocols
are consistent with international standards. Such conduct might fall within
the definition of “torture and other forms of cruel, inhuman and degrading
treatment.”
Additionally, the report fails to mention the medicines provided by the
government health insurance system to persons with psychological disabilities.
A number of drugs needed by these patients are not included on the list of
medicines provided by the government in line with the health insurance
scheme. According to many psychiatric patients, government and private
insurance systems do not make available many necessary drugs. Those who
have the financial means are forced to buy these drug at their own costs.4
Although the State of Palestine acceded to the UN Convention on the Rights of
Persons with Disabilities in 2014, a legal framework for this group of persons has
not been put forward yet. Developed in 2012, the Draft Law on Psychological
Health has not been approved. No relevant bylaws have been compiled in
reference of effective laws, particularly the Public Health Law of 2004. A brief
reference is made to that group under the 2004 Bylaw of the 1999 Law on
Persons with Disabilities.
• In relation to violence in schools
Although it falls within the purview of the Convention, the State’s report makes
no reference to school violence and government actions taken to prevent it.
According to the PCBS, 25 percent of children in the 12-17 age group were
4
For more information, see ICHR, Rights of persons benefiting from psychological health services in
Palestine, 2017, available at www.ichr.ps.
18