From Four Nodes of History: The Human Rights Challenge in the Philippine Security Sector
But General Wainwright and his staff had lost their fighting
spirit and failed to figure out that they were surrounded by a
very much smaller – though determined – force that was now
extremely weak. At that moment he could have destroyed
Homma’s entire force in a major counter-attack.
Homma’s forces were finally reinforced, bringing them back
to their former strength, upon the direct intercession of the
Japanese Emperor. Bataan fell when Homma resumed the offensive.
Homma was dumbfounded when the USAFFE surrendered
with 75,000 troops on April 9, 1942. All along he had been
thinking there were at most 25,000 manning Bataan.33 Homma shifted his attention to Corregidor, which eventually surrendered with 13,000 USAFFE troops. All in all, 88,000 USAFFE
prisoners were taken in Bataan and Corregidor. MacArthur,
with a small party, escaped using PT boats.
Had MacArthur just let his three tactical commands (North,
South, and Visayas-Mindanao) carry out guerrilla warfare
using regular troops (i.e., trading space for advantage and
refusing decisive battles), the 14th Japanese Army with only
three Divisions would have been overstretched and logistically drained to accomplish anything.
82
Based on MacArthur’s unpublished manuscript (which he did
not have published in his lifetime, possibly because of his embarrassing faulty leadership), Japan’s intent in the Philippines
was primarily to control the air and naval bases. They were
recognized as strategic to protect Japan’s hold on Southeast
Asia and not for economic reasons, unlike in China and the
rest of Southeast Asia.
The poor leadership of MacArthur and his flight to Australia
had cost the Filipino people and the USAFFE a tremendous
toll in lives, destruction of property and much humiliation
and suffering. MacArthur was not reprimanded nor retired;
instead, he was given the highest military medal of the US,
the Medal of Honor, and assigned to lead all allied forces.
He was also given the absolute authority to reorganize the
Philippine commonwealth and the army prior to the granting
of independence.
Long after MacArthur’s death, a journalist exposed a scandal that tarnished the General’s reputation. On January
1, 1942, President Quezon, afraid that the United States
would abandon the Philippines, apparently issued bribes
in the form of Commonwealth-issued checks to ranking
US Commanders in the Philippines so that they will give