– Limited recognition of changes to gender identity
The failure to recognise and to facilitate formal changes to one’s gender identity continues to
have a significant impact on transgender persons. The impact of the absence of formal legal
recognition of changes to gender identity is specifically manifest in the capacity to obtain
legal documentation that accurately reflects ones’ chosen gender identity. Amongst other
things, transgender persons are unable to obtain birth certificates, identity cards, driver
licenses and passports in their chosen gender. As a result they are often unable, or find it
difficult to participate in public life, to access essential health and social services, or travel
freely.
In the Asia Pacific region legislative provisions allowing changes to gender identity are rare,
as are judicial developments in this regard. While a small number of countries facilitate
formal recognition of changes to gender identity without medical intervention, many require
gender reassignment surgery as a pre-condition to doing so. Indeed, in some contexts there
have been extra-legal injunctions against gender reassignment surgery which further inhibit
the enjoyment of rights and increase stigmatisation of transgender people.
Annex 1 below provides a table listing the whether States permit formal changes to gender
identity.
TOR 4 – Other laws, policies and practices
Term of reference 4 asks the ACJ to advise on whether, in the course of undertaking the
reference, it has identified other laws, policies, acts or practices that impact adversely
persons on the basis of sexual orientation and gender identity, and, if so, the extent to which
those laws, policies, acts or practices are inconsistent with international human rights law
and the nature of the inconsistency.
– Introduction
Notwithstanding the constitutional, legislative and judicial developments discussed above, a
wide range of laws, policies and practices continue to undermine the capacity of persons of
diverse sexual orientation and gender identity to enjoy the full range of human rights.
– Advances
As has been articulated above, there have been some significant advances at both the
legislative and judicial level, with a number of jurisdictions decriminalising same sex sexual
conduct by consenting adults, as well as explicitly recognising sexual orientation and gender
identity as proscribed grounds of discrimination under domestic law. Recognition of changes
to gender identity is also permissible in some states.
In addition, a number of unique inquiries have been undertaken at the national level to
understand, document and advocate for the removal of discriminatory laws, policies and
practices. A study undertaken by the Australian Human Rights Commission was successful
in advancing significant changes to institutional discrimination in that country. 76 A similar
76 Same-Sex: Same Entitlements (SSSE) Report, National Inquiry into Discrimination against People in Same Sex
Relationships:
Financial
and
Work-Related
Entitlements
and
Benefits,
May
2007,
www.humanrights.gov.au/human_rights/samesex/report/index.html accessed on 26 May 2010.
ACJ Report: Human Rights, Sexual Orientation and Gender Identity
25