3 | Human rights risks and challenges
(b) Aotearoa New Zealand’s tangata whenua
Building meaningful engagement and partnership
with tangata whenua (the Indigenous people of
Aotearoa New Zealand) who make up 16.5% of
Aotearoa New Zealand’s population, will be a key
to the enduring success of the tournament. As is
the case for Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islanders,
tangata whenua experience structural and systemic
disadvantage due to colonisation, including the
confiscation and alienation by the Crown of the vast
majority of Māori land.
The relationship FIFA establishes and builds with
tangata whenua will provide the essential platform
for addressing both the risks and significant
opportunities associated with the tournament.
Te Tiriti o Waitangi,69 Aotearoa New Zealand’s
foundational document, establishes the
relationship between Māori and the Crown.
It affirms the status of whānau, hapū and iwi
as tangata whenua, and recognises their preexisting rangatiratanga (sovereignty and selfdetermination). It envisages a sharing of power
and authority and a partnership of equals. Te Tiriti
requires government to work in partnership, and
share decision-making, with its Tiriti partners, and
to respect and support the rangatiratanga authority
of tangata whenua. Te Tiriti o and its principles
(Partnership, Participation, and Protection)
therefore creates the foundation and framework
for engagement with Māori. The risks, opportunities
and recommendations in, and arising out of, this
section of the report are grounded in Te Tiriti and
its principles (self‑determination, participation in
decision-making, respect for and protection of
culture, equality and non-discrimination).
Stakeholder feedback reflected the importance of
an opportunity focused approach. Opportunities for
FIFA are discussed in section 5 of this report. The
two key themes were:
30
•
the importance of focusing on the
opportunities as well as the risks, and
•
building genuine relationships early and
over time.
The starting point for the tournament must involve
the creation of a relationship with mana whenua.
Mana whenua are the tangata whenua that hold
mana, i.e. have an ancestral connection/status with
the stolen land on which the tournament will be
held. Stakeholders in NZHRC’s mana whenua and
tangata whenua-focused hui (community gathering)
emphasised that once this relationship has been
established, both parties can begin to work through
what is wanted and what can be gained from the
tournament in a mutually respectful way. Through
FIFA’s relationships with mana whenua and other
tangata whenua, more risks will come to light
specifically around the opportunities both parties
jointly decide to pursue.
Risks
Stakeholders warned against tokenistic
engagement, for example using Māori culture
and visual art with no action, systemic backing, or
relationship behind it, or inadequate consultation.
Te Tiriti affirms the position of tangata whenua as
partners, rather than advisors or stakeholders to
be merely informed of decisions. This extends to
Māori being involved at the decision-making level in
all parts of the event, not just ceremonial and visual
aspects.
A common mistake stakeholders identified is
establishing a primary partnership relationship with
local councils and engaging with their Māori teams
who could be from anywhere around the country.
This is not a substitute for creating a relationship
with Mana whenua of the area.
Failure to uphold and protect Indigenous
knowledge and cultural integrity is a significant
risk that has played out in many previous
sporting events, which has involved dishonouring
Indigenous tohu/symbols and toi/art. These risks
can be mitigated by ensuring that tangata whenua
are involved as decision makers, and have the final
say about how their cultural property is managed.