1.1 What New Zealanders Think of Asia and Her Settlers
In general, New Zealanders hold Asia in high regard. When asked about the importance of
the Asian region to New Zealand’s future, four out of five people believe that it is either
important or very important. Approximately 90% of New Zealanders believe that Asian
tourism in New Zealand will have a positive future impact on the country and strongly
endorse Asia as an export market. A majority also believe in the benefits to New Zealand of
the economic growth in Asia (80%), free trade agreements between NZ and Asia (78%), and
NZ tourism in Asia (74%). Asian migrants are seen as contributing significantly to NZ society
(81%) and are felt to bring valuable diversity to the country (78%; Asia: NZ Foundation,
2009).
The flip side to the perceived
positive impact of Asia on New
Zealand is the less optimistic view
about the costs to New Zealand
society that come with a closer
relationship with Asia. A smaller
majority of people believe that NZ
benefits from: Asian imports to NZ
(63%), Asian cultures and values
(59%), Asian immigration (55%)
and the population growth in Asia
(47%; Asia: NZ Foundation, 2009).
When attitudes towards immigrants
and immigration are assessed,
about one in two New Zealanders
feel the recent arrival of many Asian migrants is changing NZ in undesirable ways. And
almost one in two people believe that Asians are over-represented in crime, whereas only
2.5% of those actually incarcerated identify as Asian (which is far lower than the 9% Asian
population at large; Gendall, Spoonley & Trlin, 2007). Taken together, these findings point to
the idea that some New Zealanders are happy to have a one-way relationship with Asia,
where they wish NZ to benefit economically, but they would like to keep New Zealand
society and values distant from Asian influence and not quite inclusive of Asian people.
The less positive views towards Asian influence on New Zealand society, and more strongly,
the anxieties that some New Zealanders hold about the potential (negative) impact that the
greater influx of Asian migration will bring to New Zealand, has perhaps led to an increase in
prejudice, racism and discrimination being exhibited towards Asian inhabitants in recent
years. When New Zealanders are asked to identify which group (ethnic or otherwise) faces
the most discrimination, Asians have been cited first year after year. In the 2009 UMR
Research report on perceived discrimination in NZ, 75% of respondents believed that Asians
experienced either a “great deal” or “some” discrimination, compared to the somewhat fewer
number of people who believe Pacific peoples (58%) and Māori (56%) face discrimination
(UMR Research Ltd, 2009).
5