not include Māori with lived experience
of disability. Where Crown organisations
show responsiveness to people with lived
experience of disability, this does not
usually include Māori. In turn, this leads to
a sense of Crown inaction when it comes to
the health and well-being interests of Māori
with lived experience of disability.84
Recognising the intersection of identities and
experiences is crucial to ensuring responses are
diverse and meet the needs of every individual.
Violence and abuse tāngata whaikaha Māori
face cannot be looked at from a traditional
model of harm against disabled people, or harm
against Indigenous people. It is both. A one-sizefits-all model fails to acknowledge and respond
to the intersecting nature of indigeneity and
disability.
In its Hauora report the Tribunal recognised
that where there are severe and persistent
inequities, the Government’s Tiriti obligations
are heightened.85 The deeper the need, the more
urgent and substantial a targeted response
should be. The cumulative disadvantage and
discrimination, marginalisation, and inequities
tāngata whaikaha experience leave no doubt
that the obligations on Government to take
action and give these issues particular priority
and urgency, are heightened.
The intergenerational impacts of violence
against tangata whaikaha
The impact of violence and abuse against
tāngata whaikaha Māori has ongoing,
intergenerational impacts. Violence and abuse,
accompanied by experiences of colonisation,
racism, discrimination, ableism and other socioeconomic issues, compound disadvantage for
tāngata whaikaha Māori. The Te Hau Tangata
strategy recognises that unresolved trauma
impacts successive generations. The strategy
notes:
“Exposure to, and experience of violence
has long-term and complex effects. This
compounds with all other forms of trauma
which, if left unaddressed, can have far
reaching impacts on people’s wellbeing”.86
16
Human Rights Commission
Colonisation should be understood as
a contributor to the intergenerational
transmission of trauma.87 The trauma of
colonisation continues to impact successive
generations of Māori who experience
disproportionate rates of violence, alongside
racism, discrimination and other negative
effects. Tāngata whaikaha Māori feel trauma
in distinct ways linked to these experiences. As
was noted by the Family Death Violence Review
Committee:
“The historical and ongoing impact of
colonisation, which includes unchecked
privilege, and how colonisation contributes
to chronic and complex trauma for
both individuals and communities ... are
central reasons why Māori and non-Māori
experience violence across generations”.88
Colonisation and the dislocation that
accompanied it, caused many tāngata whaikaha
Māori to become disconnected from their
whānau. This disconnect occurred for several
reasons including institutionalisation, abuse and
violence, drug and alcohol abuse, adoption, and
removal by Oranga Tamariki. This displacement
was abusive, and today continues to contribute
to the possibility of abuse.89
Not only is it alarming that rates of violence
are higher for tāngata whaikaha Māori, but
the flow-on effects for generations of Māori
are immeasurable. Exposure to violence leads
to feelings of helplessness, intergenerational
trauma, loss of identity, and fear. Violence
creates intergenerational risks that children
who witness or experience violence will go on to
become involved in violence in adulthood.90
Because of the collective nature of Māori
society, not only is the harm inflicted on tangata
whaikaha Māori individuals problematic, but
the wider whānau of that individual is also
affected. Tāngata whaikaha Māori are often best
supported by their whānau, notwithstanding
that lack of government support and services
often means these responsibilities and duties
must fall on whānau. It is therefore imperative
that whānau receive and have access to support
as well.