This involves a significant cultural shift in the
operation of federal discrimination laws, albeit
a shift that has been occurring in discrimination
laws in other jurisdictions and in work, health
and safety laws.
Positive duties are an emerging feature of
discrimination laws in Australia and overseas,
reflecting a shift to a preventative focus that
is proactive in dealing with discrimination and
avoiding harm.
The current model of federal discrimination
laws is heavily dependent on individuals
bringing forward complaints of discriminatory
treatment as the only available method for
enforcing the law. We know that many people
who have been discriminated against and
treated unlawfully will never take such action.
The Commission’s report, Respect@Work:
National inquiry into Sexual Harassment in
Australian Workplaces (2020), recommended
a positive duty to take measures to eliminate
discrimination, sexual harassment and
victimisation as far as possible.
To do so, requires a person to be prepared to
relive an incident or pattern of behaviour that
may have been deeply hurtful or traumatic
for them. It requires them to have enough
knowledge of the law, and/or of how to get
legal assistance, even to know that their
treatment may be unlawful. It involves a
significant investment of time and often, money.
It also requires them to exercise bravery and,
in some instances, to risk experiencing further
adverse consequences from stepping forward.
Those most likely to experience discrimination on
a regular basis may be less likely to bring individual
actions. They are often the least resourced and
least supported in our community to do so, and
the cumulative impact of their exposure to such
treatment on a regular basis may leave them
the most disempowered in the community.
The Commission’s report, Wiyi Yanu U
Thangani: Women’s Voices (2020),8 is a vivid
illustration of this. It details regular experiences
of discrimination faced by Aboriginal and
Torres Strait Islander women and girls – most
of which goes unaddressed.
Ensuring that there are remedies for those
subject to discrimination is fundamental. It
is a key component to meeting obligations
to respect, protect and fulfil the right to
non‑discrimination.
As illustrated in Text Box 2, the Sex
Discrimination Act was amended in 2022 to
implement the positive duty in relation to
sexual harassment and related situations.
Enforcement powers of the Commission
relating to this positive duty commence in
December 2023.
However, sexual harassment and discrimination
in the workplace are only one aspect of matters
covered by federal discrimination law. The
Commission considers that a broader positive
duty incorporating all discrimination laws is
essential if Australia is to achieve the goal of
the elimination of discrimination.
This language is clearly reflected in Australia’s
international obligations. For example, Article 2
of the ICERD states the commitment that
Australia, and all other governments, have
made is to eliminate racial discrimination in all
its forms.
The Commission therefore proposes that
a positive duty be a central reform to all
discrimination laws to place a new, significant
focus on the prevention of discrimination.
Complaints mechanisms are, therefore, of
critical importance, but such mechanisms
should not be the first or only mechanism for
addressing discrimination, because they are
focused on redress rather than prevention.
82
That was based on the model in Victoria that
has been in place since 2010.9 The Commission
considered that the positive duty should be
part of a new regulatory model in relation to
the continuing problem of sexual harassment in
the workplace.
Such a duty would extend beyond the
workplace, to all areas of public life, and
incorporate all protected grounds.
FREE & EQUAL: Revitalising Australia’s Commitment to Human Rights