Together, these human rights standards recognise and affirm the fundamental
importance of land to the identity, culture and rights of indigenous peoples. When
translated into the context of Aotearoa New Zealand, they highlight the human rights
commitments of the New Zealand Government to both protect Māori rights to land
and culture and to provide a fully rights-consistent and participatory decision-making
framework.
Central to the right to participation is the right of indigenous peoples to free, prior
and informed consent – one of the most important procedural principles in the
Declaration. Disagreements within indigenous communities about whether free,
prior and informed consent has been achieved, should be resolved by the
indigenous peoples, using their own laws, traditions, customs, and representative
institutions.
The Government, for its part, should ensure that consultation processes support
consensus building, are non-coercive and do not cause division.
The human rights principles set out in the Declaration also reinforce traditional Te
Ao Māori values and concepts that apply to the land, its guardianship and its cultural
and spiritual significance for mana whenua.
In summary, the Declaration provides a helpful lens through which the situation at
Ihumātao can be viewed, including:
•
Whether there are adequate legal protections or avenues to ensure that land
of considerable cultural and heritage value to mana whenua is adequately
protected.
•
The nature and extent of consultation regarding decisions to approve the
housing development under the Special Housing Act and the unavailability
of a legal process to challenge the decision.
•
The nature and extent of consultation regarding decisions to develop the
land, particularly negotiations with Fletcher Building.
•
The nature and extent of discussions about resolving the current situation
and finding an appropriate way forward.
•
Whether previous processes have enabled all mana whenua affected by the
housing development to properly participate.
5