Part II: Preventing torture: NHRIs in action
It might be difficult for a man to interview a woman, even when the subject matter of the interview is
not sensitive. A woman is often more willing to talk to another woman. This consideration is especially
important when discussing an experience of a violation of sexual nature. It is difficult enough for a
woman to talk to anyone about an experience of this nature and a man, however sympathetic, is
likely to trigger fears and feelings of vulnerability associated with the assault. However, it is important
to avoid making assumptions regarding women’s preferences and ensure that the interviewee can
choose to speak to a woman or a man.
Interviewing children
Children’s best interest should always prevail when planning and conducting interviews, including
considering whether it is really necessary to carry out the interview in the first place and if the information
can be obtained through other means. It is also important for interviewers to be adequately trained on
child development and specific techniques for interviewing children.
Children perceive the world very differently from adults and this fact should be appreciated when
preparing to interview a child. The issue of power relations should also be carefully considered, as a
child may be more likely to provide compliant answers.
The age, developmental stage, education and prior experiences of the child must also be taken into
account, as this will greatly influence the child’s capacity to tell their story. For instance, can the child
talk freely and uninterrupted? Or are they better able to respond to specific questions?
If the interview relates to an allegation of physical abuse, a child is likely to feel anxious and reticent
to discuss the issue. It is important to be extremely patient. Often several interviews will be necessary
before a child will trust you sufficiently to confide in you. It may also be helpful to consider using other
methods of communication, such as drawing or using pictures or images (sad faces / smiley faces).
The child should be asked whether they have a preference regarding the gender of the interviewer.
During an interview, you should also be attentive to signs that the child is growing anxious or
overwhelmed and, when necessary, offer a break or interrupt the interview.
Other specific issues to be carefully considered when interviewing children include:
• Obtaining the informed consent of the parent(s) or legal guardian to talk to the child, as well as
the child’s consent (if age allows).
• Ensuring a safe and private location as well as sitting arrangements that could make the child
more comfortable, for example by avoiding sitting behind a desk.
• Making sure from the beginning that the child understands the purpose and process of the
interview.
• Using simple language adapted to the child’s age and development stage.
• Reducing note-taking.
Interviewing LGBTI persons
In certain contexts, it may be particularly challenging to gather information on human rights violations
directly from LGBTI persons for a number of reasons, including security, risk of harm, trauma and
stigma. NHRIs may therefore seek to obtain information on the situation of LGBTI persons also from
other sources, such as associations and organisations that protect their rights. It is also crucial that all
data is treated confidentially and that this is clearly explained to the interviewee.
NHRIs should be trained on LGBTI issues prior to carrying out interviews with LGBTI persons. When
interviewing LGBTI persons, it is important to use appropriate language, to avoid pressuring the
person to disclose their sexual orientation or gender identity by posing direct questions, and to send a
clear message of non-discrimination. The interviewer should refrain from making assumptions on the
person’s sexual orientation or gender identity, and refer to the person by using the terms, pronouns
and names they choose.
75