Chapter 1 – Report of the Policy, Law and Complaints Group
(v)
Working Conditions of Police Personnel
Apart from the rights of detainees, the Commission also studied the working conditions of
police personnel.
Healthcare of police personnel is a serious concern especially for those who process detainees
because they are exposed to the risk of infectious diseases such as tuberculosis. They also
face risks when handling drug users; for example, there had been incidents where drug users
flung used needles at them during arrest. According to the police personnel interviewed,
there was no periodic medical screening or immunisation for them.
Workload is another concern raised by the police personnel interviewed in the study,
especially among the investigation officers (IO). The IOs claimed that too many files were
assigned to them and this has led to a backlog of cases. The IOs were required to multitask,
for example they were also assigned for duty during roadblocks, raids, and football matches,
and were expected to escort dignitaries and take part in other programmes. Some of the
IOs confessed that they have had to apply for remand orders for suspects simply because
they had limited time to conduct investigations.
During the study, the Commission observed that about 20 per cent of the IOs are between the
ages of 51 to 60 years. It was highlighted to the Commission that the age factor sometimes
hampers investigation work.
Other common problems observed by the Commission are the poor facilities and operational
logistics of the police stations. Almost all the district police headquarters (IPD) visited by
the Commission, including the newly built ones, had been facing problems. Among the
problems were short-circuited electricity supply, malfunction of air conditioners and lifts, and
maintenance of police vehicles. In addition, some personnel have had to work in unconducive
environments, for example, where a small office space had to be shared among three to
four persons. They have also had to share facilities like computers, printers, and cartridges.
Most of them had to fork out their own money to buy A4 paper and ink cartridges due to
shortage of supply.
The issues raised above are potential contributors of unnecessary stress and pressure, which
could lead to other problems such as corruption and the release of frustration on detainees
as admitted by some of the personnel during the study.
(b)
Recommendations
The Commission is in the midst of finalising the report on deaths in police custody, which
contains details of issues as well as specific recommendations. The Commission’s general
recommendations in relation to the issues raised above are summarised below:
75
BOOK-ANR2016-01-latest.indb 75
08/04/2016 3:32 PM