Conceptualizing and Measuring Democracy
27
In 2009, after observing that conditions have not remarkably improved
and that attempted reforms appear to mostly fail to transform, the PHDR's
phrasing of the institutional problems confronting the country and its
reformers markedly changes. Without lapsing into the activist language of
ideological speechmakers, the PHDR, in reacting to the country's deteriorated
position between 1997 and 2007 as charted by the World Governance Indicators
on a range of governance concerns (rule of law, regulatory quality, control of
corruption, government effectiveness and voice and accountability), pointedly
remarks:
The drop in the Philippines' ranking in the WGI between 1996 and 2007 is alarming
though not surprising. The country has long been described as a 'soft state,' where
rules and enforcement are for sale [Fabella, 2008]. There is wide agreement that the
weakness of political institutions in the Philippines is a major, if not the major,
hindrance to its further progress (HDN 2009: 2). [Bold type that of the Report]
A similar sense of frustration and even cynicism regarding the wardens of
political governance is detectible in many parts of the 2009 PHDR. Speaking of
key institutions administering the national bureaucracy, exacting political
accountability from public officials and overseeing the nation's judicial system,
the Report is unable to rule out the political intrusions that would weaken and
disable the functional objectives of these critical institutions .
And there lies the rub. For in all three organizations which concern us—the Civil
Service Commission, the Office of the Ombudsman, and the Supreme
Court—performance has been affected in varying degrees, and is anticipated to be
further affected, by the direct or indirect interference from, or circumvention of rules
by, the appointing authority (PHDR 2009: 43).
Indeed there lies the rub, when economists traditionally known for
conservative writing, dramatically start their assessment of national human
development in the Philippines with the poetry of the oppressed from another
age, when despotism, oligarchy and national plunder made the poet Francisco
Baltazar protest more than a hundred years earlier:
Sa loob at labas ng bayan kong sawi,
kaliluha'y siyang nangyayaring hari,
kagalinga't bait ay nalulugami,
ininis sa hukay ng dusa't pighati (PHDR 2009: 1).
[In and around my unfortunate nation,
Deceit and treason reign,
Virtue and reason are shamed,
Suffocated in the grave of sorrow and pain.]