The Mental Health Commissioner (2021)84
reported “The rate of Māori held under the
Mental Health Act compulsory treatment orders
continues to be high. In 2018, 28% of those subject
to compulsory treatment orders were Māori.ξ
Gender-diverse disabled people
In 2017, Dickson85 surveyed gender-diverse
disabled people about their experiences of
partner violence and abuse. All of the 159
people who responded to the survey had
experienced abuse from a partner. This included
sexual, verbal, emotional and psychological
abuse, isolation and threatening behaviour. This
has been reiterated for disabled trans and nonbinary people who report high levels of violence
and abuse including a seven times increased risk
of sexual violence.86
People with learning disability
The Donald Beasley Institute, a centre for
learning disability research, has not carried out
any research specifically about abuse, but reports
findings about abuse in many of the studies it
does undertake. For example, research into the
institutionalisation of disabled people found:
Neglect was common… Emotional and
psychological abuse was seen through
people talking about being scared a lot of
the time. People…said they were unable to
make decisions because they had always
ξ
been made for them…Most people said they
had been physically restrained or controlled
in some way…Most people had been
physically abused…Sexual abuse started
when the person was a child and was often
kept secret until they were adults. People
did not talk about it because they were
ashamed, and they thought they would
not be believed. Those who did report that
they had been sexually abused were not
supported…Institutions followed Pākehā
customs and did not allow for Māori or
Pasifika customs to be part of people’s lives.
Most said they did not have control of their
money and things that they treasured were
often stolen.87
Research about learning disabled people’s
experience of the Aotearoa justice system
identified that:
… abuse, both physical and sexual, was
evident amongst the group of New
Zealand men and women with intellectual
disability who participated in this study.
Of the 40 individuals who took part in this
study approximately half the women and
one third of the men disclosed that they
had been physically or sexually abused.
This is likely to be an underestimate as
participants were not directly asked to
disclose experiences of abuse, but rather
offered this sensitive information during the
interview process.88
The Director of Mental Health’s annual report covering 2018 and 2019, issued in 2021, reports rates of compulsory
treatment per 100,000 of the general population by DHB. These statistics support the conclusion that “Māori were more likely
to be assessed or treated under the Mental Health Act than non-Māori” (p. 1). The report states that in 2018 “Māori made up
approximately 16 percent of New Zealand’s population, yet they accounted for 28 percent of all mental health service users.” (p. 18)
and that [based on age-standardised rates per 100,000 population] “Māori were 4 times more likely than non-Māori to be subject
to a community treatment order and 3.7 times more likely to be subject to an inpatient treatment order” (p. 18).
The report says “In 2019: 6.6 percent of Māori accessed mental health and addiction services, compared with 3.2 percent of
non-Māori
• Māori were 3.8 times more likely than non-Māori to be subject to a community treatment order and 3.6 times more likely to
be subject to an inpatient treatment order
• Māori males were the population group most likely to be subject to community and inpatient treatment orders (compared
with non-Māori males and Māori and non-Māori females)
• DHBs varied in their ratio of Māori to non-Māori subject to community and inpatient treatment orders
• on average, Māori and non-Māori remained on community and inpatient treatment orders for similar lengths of time
• Māori were 2.9 times more likely to be subject to indefinite community treatment orders than non-Māori, and 2.7 times more
likely to be subject to indefinite inpatient treatment orders than non-Māori
• Māori made up approximately 17% of New Zealand’s population, yet they accounted for 29% of all mental health service users
• approximately half of all Māori service users were under 25 years of age, compared with approximately 29% of non-Māori
service users
• among service users under a community treatment order, 79% of Māori were living in the most deprived deciles (8–10),
compared with 30 percent of non-Māori” (pp. 18/19).
Acting now for a violence and abuse free future
31