limited English felt limited in their ability to progress
in their workplace and are also vulnerable to being
forced to work in illegal working conditions or not
claiming contractual benefits.200 Research on the
settlement experiences of Pacific migrants in New
Zealand also shows that Pacific migrants with English
proficiency are more likely to be employed.201
Pacific workers can also be socially isolated at
work. Research has found that Pacific workers
report being actively made to feel as if they do not
belong with their Pākehā co-workers and being
excluded from social events.202 This was made
clear by the participants in Tupou’s research on
Pacific women’s experiences of the glass ceiling in
various occupations.203 One woman described her
experiences of isolation within the workplace: “I feel
left out, all my female colleagues went out for lunch
one day, they don’t invite me, I was really sad, maybe
because I am a Pacific woman.”204 Other participants
reported being made fun of for their skin colour or
food, even when invited to social gatherings such as
lunch.205 Despite this treatment within the workplace,
Pacific workers in this study recognised that these
social events were key to networking and career
progression and were frustrated at their exclusion.206
One participant cited by Tupou noted: “The rules and
the structure of my workplace were designed to suit
men, the boss socialised with the white men at work;
they used to go out for sport events, nothing for us
women.”207 The experiences of Tupou’s participants
in being actively excluded from important networking
30
and social events are consistent with literature that
finds that non-white workers, especially women,
frequently report such an issue.208 Social exclusion
becomes a further issue when it also impacts a
person’s perception of self-worth. Being excluded
both socially and in workplace progression often
affects work productivity and the likelihood of being
promoted.209 This is neatly summarised by a Pacific
woman in Tupou’s study: “I just do my best, I don’t go
the extra mile because my manager won’t take any
notice.”210
5.1.5 Pacific leaders in the workplace
Pacific workers in leadership roles report
discrimination and disconnection from other Pacific
peoples. Pacific workers reported being denied
entry to locations within company premises as
people do not believe they are in leadership roles.211
Interestingly, progression in the workplace for some
Pacific workers meant a severing of relationships
with their Pacific colleagues as they moved from
peer to supervisor, which could be at odds with the
shared Pacific values of collectively and reciprocity.212
Pacific workplace leaders report that, the higher they
climb within their industry, the less likely it is that
other Pacific people will tell you when something
has gone wrong. This can be a difficult and isolating
experience.213 These narratives make clear that
progression in and of itself is not a solution for Pacific
workers’ experiences of discrimination and isolation
within workplaces in Aotearoa New Zealand.
200
Auckland Co-design Lab, The Attitude Gap Challenge, 16.
201
Sin and Ormsby, The Settlement Experience of Pacific Migrants in New Zealand, 21-22.
202
Tupou, “The Effect of the Glass Ceiling,” 46.
203
Tupou, “The Effect of the Glass Ceiling,” 44.
204
Tupou, “The Effect of the Glass Ceiling,” 44.
205
Tupou, “The Effect of the Glass Ceiling,” 44.
206
Tupou, “The Effect of the Glass Ceiling,” 46, 55; Radio New Zealand. “Workplace Challenges for Pasifika Peoples – Brown
Glass Ceiling.” Nine to Noon (podcast), February 11, 2019, accessed July 12, 2021. https://www.rnz.co.nz/national/
programmes/ninetonoon/audio/2018681954/workplace-challenges-for-pasifika-peoples-brown-glass-ceiling.
207
Tupou, “The Effect of the Glass Ceiling,” 55.
208
Tupou, “The Effect of the Glass Ceiling,” 24; Mesui, Mary. “Pacific Island Women’s Experiences of the ‘Brown Glass Ceiling’
in Senior Management in Aotearoa New Zealand.” Master’s thesis, Auckland University of Technology, 2019, 15. https://
openrepository.aut.ac.nz/handle/10292/12621.
209
Radio New Zealand, “Workplace Challenges for Pasifika Peoples.”
210
Tupou, “The Effect of Glass Ceilings,” 55.
211
Radio New Zealand, “Workplace Challenges for Pasifika Peoples.”
212
Auckland Co-design Lab, The Attitude Gap Challenge, 15.
213
Feilo, “Talanoa,” 53.