how neoliberalism impacts Pacific peoples working
in universities.40 However, research exploring gender
pay gaps in Aotearoa New Zealand has not explored
the intersectional pay gaps faced by Pacific women.41
regarding how neoliberalism impacts the Pacific Pay
Gap and the workplace experiences of Pacific peoples.
For example, in a study by McGregor et al. on the
experiences of female engineers in seeking equal
pay in Aotearoa New Zealand, the authors argue
that the gender pay gap is connected to neoliberal
laws and policies of individualised negotiation and
bargaining.42 However, the authors did not have
Pacific women engineers in their sample43 and were
thus unable to explore the unique intersectional
experiences of Pacific women engineers. A similar
intersectional study by Pringle et al. drew on some
of the same data as McGregor et al. but looked at
gender pay equity for women in caring occupations
as well as engineering in Aotearoa New Zealand.44
Here, the authors investigated the intersections
of gender and class rather than any intersections
with ethnicity, explaining they “gave a central place
to class, partly because class is not a justiciable
inequality in NZ, nor in similar jurisdictions”.45
Post-World War II, New Zealand faced a labour
shortage that led to changes in New Zealand’s
immigration policies.46 The New Zealand Government
actively encouraged Pacific peoples in the Pacific
Islands to migrate to Aotearoa New Zealand to fill
the shortage,47 specifically low-paid jobs that many
Pākehā New Zealanders did not want to do, including
shift work, factory work, assembly line production,
processing and cleaning.48 As a result, Pacific
migrants came in large waves on temporary visas,
resulting in the Pacific population growing from 3,600
in 1951 to over 50,000 in 1972.49 During this time,
government enforcement against the overstaying of
visas was relaxed.50
Therefore, there is an apparent need for further
research to fill this critical gap in the literature
10
2.6 Pacific peoples and the Dawn Raids
However, the economic recession of 1973 saw Pacific
migrants being scapegoated by politicians and the
media by being blamed for rising unemployment
and unrest.51 Accordingly, the Labour Government
suspended its relaxed approach to temporary visas,
and a Police task force was commissioned to initiate
40
Naepi, Sereana. “Pacific Women’s Experiences Working in Universities in Aotearoa New Zealand.” Higher Education Research
& Development 40, no. 1 (2021): 63-74; Kidman, Joanna, and Cherie Chu. “‘We’re not the Hottest Ethnicity’: Pacific Scholars
and the Cultural Politics of New Zealand Universities.” Globalisation, Societies and Education 17 (2019): 489-499; Barber,
Simon, and Sereana Naepi. “Sociology in a Crisis: Covid-19 and the Colonial Politics of Knowledge Production in Aotearoa
New Zealand.” Journal of Sociology 56 (2020): 693-703.
41
McGregor, Judy, Sharyn Graham Davies, Lynne S. Giddings, and Judith Pringle. “Pursuing Equal Pay: The Perspectives of
Female Engineers and Potential Policy Interventions.” Journal of Industrial Relations 59 (2017): 3-21; Pringle, Judith, Sharyn
Davies, Lynne Giddings, and Judy McGregor. “Gender Pay Equity and Wellbeing: An Intersectional Study of Engineering
and Caring Occupations.” New Zealand Journal of Employment Relations 42, no. 3 (2017): 29-45; Graham Davies, Sharyn, Judy
McGregor, Judith Pringle, and Lynne Giddings. “Rationalizing Pay Inequity: Women Engineers, Pervasive Patriarchy and the
Neoliberal Chimera.” Journal of Gender Studies 27, no. 6 (2018): 623-636; Douglas, Julie, and Katherine Ravenswood. “‘We
Can’t Afford Pay Equity’: Examining Pay Equity and Equal Pay Policy in a Neoliberal Environment.” New Zealand Sociology 34
(2019): 175-199; Parker, Jane, and Noelle Donnelly. “The Revival and Refashioning of Gender Pay Equity in New Zealand.”
Journal of Industrial Relations 62 (2020): 560-581.
42
McGregor et al., “Pursuing Equal Pay,” 15-16.
43
McGregor et al., “Pursuing Equal Pay,” 9.
44
Pringle et al., “Gender Pay Equity and Wellbeing”.
45
Pringle et al., “Gender Pay Equity and Wellbeing,” 32.
46
Bedford, Richard. “Skilled Migration in and out of New Zealand: Immigrants, Workers, Students and Emigrants.”
In Evaluation of the General Skilled Migration Categories Report, edited by Bob Birrell, Lesleyanne Hawthorne, and
Sue Richardson, 221-225. Canberra: Commonwealth of Australia, 2006. https://citeseerx.ist.psu.edu/viewdoc/
download?doi=10.1.1.476.8583&rep=rep1&type=pdf.
47
Fraenkel, Jon. Pacific Islands and New Zealand – Immigration and Aid. Te Ara – the Encyclopedia of New Zealand. https://teara.
govt.nz/mi/pacific-islands-and-new-zealand/print.
48
Lay, Graeme. Pacific New Zealand. Auckland: David Ling Publishing, 1996, 13.
49
Gibson, Katherine. “Political Economy and International Labour Migration: The Case of Polynesians in New Zealand.”
New Zealand Geographer, 9 (1983): 31.
50
Ministry for Pacific Peoples. Dawn Raids Apology. https://www.mpp.govt.nz/about-us/dawn-raids-apology/.
51
Anae, Melani. “All Power to the People: Overstayers, Dawn Raids and the Polynesian Panthers.” In Tangata o Le Moana: New
Zealand and the People of the Pacific, edited by Sean Mallon, Kolokesa Mahina-Tuai, and Damon Salesa. Wellington: Te Papa
Press, 2012, 223.