Annual Report
2013-14
others. The fact that the deceased Kallu was able to commit suicide was in itself a proof that
the State failed in its duty towards a person in its custody. For this negligence, which led
to a uncalled death, the Commission believed it would be appropriate for the State to make
reparations. The Commission thus directed the Government of the NCT of Delhi to show
cause as to why it should not recommend monetary relief for the next of kin of the deceased
Kallu alias Veeru.
4.22 Responding to the Commission’s notice, the Special Secretary, Home Department,
Government of NCT of Delhi contended that the deceased did not die due to any external
injury and submitted that there was no foul play in the death of the deceased. Further,
suspicion raised by the family members was not substantiated in the postmortem and for
those reasons there was no criminal negligence on the part of the jail administration.
4.23 The Commission did not accept the above contention of the State and observed that
the fact remained that the deceased died due to hanging. The question put forth by the
Commission was that the negligence on the part of the prison officials had led the deceased
to hang himself within the prison premises. The magisterial enquiry also revealed that the
incident could have been avoided if greater care had been taken by the prison officials.
Hence, the Commission held that there was negligence on part of the jail administration due
to which the deceased committed suicide by hanging himself in the prison.
4.24 Rejecting the defence put forth by the Government, the Commission vide its
proceedings dated 12 December 2013 recommended to the Government of NCT of Delhi
to pay a sum of `1,00,000 as monetary relief to the next of kin of the deceased Kallu alias
Veeru on proper identification. The Chief Secretary, Government of NCT of Delhi was asked
to submit compliance report along with proof of payment within a period of six weeks.
4.25
3.
Compliance report is awaited.
Death of Undertrial Prisoner K. Yadagiri Goud in Sub-jail, Chittoor, Andhra
Pradesh (Case No. 269/1/3/2011-JCD)
4.26 The Commission on 22 March 2011 took cognizance of the intimation received
from the In-charge, Police Station, Alipuri, Chittor, Andhra Pradesh regarding death of an
undertrial prisoner K. Yadagiri Goud, aged 30 years on 26 February 2011. Goud had been
lodged in the Sub-Jail-II, Chittoor, Andhra Pradesh since 30 May 2010. He reportedly fell
sick on 22 February 2011 and was taken to the District Headquarters Hospital, Chittoor
where he was treated as an out-patient and returned to the Sub-Jail on the same day. He
again complained of illness on 25 February 2011 and was admitted to the District Hospital.
On 26 February 2011, he was shifted to SVRR Government Hospital, Tirupati, where doctor
on duty declared him `brought dead’.
NHRC | 31