87
Takaparawhā | Bastion Point (1978)
The Takaparawhā | Bastion Point occupation is
an enduring example of the racist deployment of
police violence to suppress Māori grievances over
the unjust taking of whenua Māori (Harris, 2004).
The government took the land at Takaparawhā for
national security purposes in 1859, but when no
longer required for this purpose, failed to return
the land to Ngāti Whātua. In the mid-1970s, the
government and Auckland City Council agreed to
subdivide the land and sell it for luxury housing.
In 1977, the Ōrākei Māori Committee Action Group
began a 506-day long occupation of the Ōrākei
headland (Harris, 2004, pp. 78-85).
In early 1978, the Crown took an injunction and
served eviction notices against four of the protesters.
On 25 May 1978, 600 police and army personnel
were sent to forcibly remove tangata whenua.
The police arrested 222 people and destroyed the
settlement (Harris, 2004, pp. 78-85). The use of the
huge and disproportionate application of police and
military echoed Parihaka and Maungapōhatu and
reinforced the lengths the state would take to crush
just Māori protests (Aikman, 2021).
Operation Eight and Ruatoki
(2007, 2012, 2014)
On 16 January 2005, during a pōwhiri for the Waitangi
Tribunal hearing, Tāme Iti fired a shotgun at the New
Zealand flag in a re-enactment of the nineteenth
century colonial campaigns that had devastated
the Urewera Forest. Although filmed by television
crews, the police ignored the incident until an ACT
Party MP raised the matter in Parliament. Tame Iti
was convicted of discharging a firearm in a public
place in a dangerous manner. The Court of Appeal
subsequently overturned the conviction.
On 15 October 2007, Operation Eight involving 300
police acting under the Terrorism Suppression Act
(2002) raided 60 houses across New Zealand, on the
basis of unfounded suspicions raised about outdoor
camps in the Urewera. The highest profile raids
occurred in the Ngāi Tūhoe settlement of Ruatoki and
Taneātua where the Armed Offenders Squad set
up roadblocks and stopped and searched cars and
photographed occupants including children without
Human Rights Commission
required consents. The Independent Police Conduct
Authority (IPCA) would later describe the roadblocks
by Police as “unlawful, unjustified and unreasonable”
(IPCA Report, May 2013).
The IPCA report also found Police had exceeded
their authority and misinterpreted legislation. The
IPCA Chair Judge Sir David Carruthers said while the
Commissioner of Police’s decision to undertake the
operation was reasonable and justified, however:
Police had no legal basis for stopping and
searching vehicles or photographing drivers or
passengers. ‘The roadblock at Ruatoki and the
presence of armed Police officers was intimidating
and the report states that there was no
assessment of the likely impact of this activity on
the local community,’ Sir David said (IPCA Media
Release, 22 May 2013).
Eighteen people, including Tame Iti, were arrested;
they were all supporters of Te Mana Motuhake o
Tūhoe and from diverse networks of environmental,
anarchist and Māori activism. Forty-one search
warrants were executed throughout the country.
The Human Rights Commission received 31 complaints
about the police operation. Complaints included
the use of the Terrorism Suppression Act 2002, that
people were stopped at roadblocks at Ruatoki, cars
searched, and people photographed without their
consent, and children confined in their homes for
several hours, some without food. The Human Rights
Commission report stated:
Our report focuses on the innocent people
affected by the operation. These people had done
nothing wrong and did not break any laws but
had their basic rights trampled. The report does
not deal with those people arrested or charged
(Human Rights Commission, 2013, pp8-10).
Ngāi Tūhoe sent a 500-person hīkoi to parliament,
protesting at what they claimed was police terrorism
targeting Māori activists. Police claimed they had
uncovered a domestic terrorist plot and a paramilitary
training camp deep in the Urewera mountain range.
The raids in the Ruatoki Valley and elsewhere saw 17
people face a total of 291 charges under the Arms Act.
Most defendants had their charges dropped when
the Court ruled much of the evidence inadmissible.