82
Maranga Mai!
Influenza pandemic (1918)
The disastrous state of Māori health meant Māori
were far more vulnerable to the 1918 Influenza
Pandemic than Pākehā. The pandemic (the Spanish
flu) killed over 50 million people worldwide, including
9,000 in New Zealand. Māori died at a rate nine times
higher than Pākehā (Rice, 2018; Ministry for Culture
and Heritage, 2020).
Kāinga across the motu were affected. With a death
toll so high, few were well enough to look after the
sick or bury the dead. Māori MPs put aside their
parliamentary duties to help their people through the
pandemic. Pōmare returned to medicine and treated
the sick and organised Māori councils to action. Many
Māori people turned their homes into a hospital and
tended to the sick.
Many Māori parents died. Many babies were
orphaned and had to be cared for by wider whānau.
In Waikato, for example, Te Puea took personal
responsibility for 100 orphaned tamariki. The loss was
even more poignant, as it meant tamariki lost access
to their whakapapa, reo, customs and mātauranga
due to their tīpuna, parents, uncles and aunties dying.
We can now only wonder what difference Pōmare’s
proposed network of Māori hospitals might have
made to those tamariki and whānau and those
generations still to come.
Racism and Māori
health today
Considerable research has been conducted about the
link between racism and health. This makes it clear
that racism is “an underlying cause of ethnic health
inequalities in Aotearoa New Zealand” (Talamaivao,
Harris, Cormak, Paine & King, 2020, p. 55; Human
Rights Commission, 2012, p. 18; Harris, Stanley &
Cormack, 2018, p. 2).
Māori disproportionately experience racism across
the health system (Talamaivao et al, 2020, p. 63). This
effect is felt across the sector since Māori patients
presenting to the health system, as well as Māori
health workers working in the system, experience
it. One Māori Registered Nurse reported being
patronised by some of her patients, who would “speak
slowly and enunciate their words more clearly as if
I were stupid and didn’t understand them”. Another
described “two geriatric patients who just didn’t want
to be attended by me because I was black” (Huria et
al, 2014, p. 368).
The feeling of being spoken down to, or thought of
somehow being ‘less than others’, is how Māori have
long felt in their engagements with the health system.
A collection of Māori experiences in health services
shows this (Jansen, Bacal & Crengle, 2008, p. 44):
Māori feel clinicians think, ‘Oh, there they are
again, bludgers. No Māori wants to feel as if
he’s a bludger’.
White medical staff all look at us in that way.
They’re always asking if you’ve got a community
card. If you are Māori, you get asked if you’ve
got a card. Have you got a community card?
I said to one doctor, ‘Would you have been so
rude if I was Pākehā?’
Inequities in health outcomes for Māori
For the Waitangi Tribunal in Hauora: Report on
Stage One of the Health Services and Outcomes
Kaupapa Inquiry (WAI 2575), the Crown’s failures in
protecting Māori health are irrefutable, exacerbated
by inadequate policy and legislative infrastructure
(Waitangi Tribunal, 2019, p. 161).
These findings are evident in the inequitable health
outcomes for Māori, where:
• Māori, in general, experience reduced healthcare
across “primary and pre-primary through to
secondary or tertiary [care] services and beyond”
(Jansen, Bacal & Crengle, 2008, p. 17).
• Māori “obtain fewer diagnostic tests, less effective
treatment plans and are referred for secondary
or tertiary procedures at lower rates than nonMāori patients”, despite comparable attendance
at GP appointments (Jansen and Jansen, 2011,
p. 53, in Human Rights Commission, 2012, p.
20). This is also apparent in comparatively low
hospitalisation rates for Māori who are highly
represented in certain disease categories (Reid
and Robson, 2007, p. 7).