It should also be added that since the mid-1990s, when many of the
original JHEOA functions were handed to other ministries (e.g. Ministry of
Education, Ministry of Health), those ministries would also have separate
allocations for their Orang Asli projects. Thus, the allocation for Orang Asli
development is a considerable one, and the government has frequently
gone to great lengths to highlight this. Unfortunately, given the social
indicators for the Orang Asli, there appears to be a gap between intention
and delivery. Clearly, there must be something wrong in the distribution
of economic projects if, while the national poverty rate has decreased to
single-digit levels, that for the Orang Asli continues to include more than
three-quarters of its population.
Cause of Underdevelopment
The reasons for this state of affairs is, needless to say, multi-faceted.
However, I would strongly agree with the comments of the then Minister of
Finance, Tun Daim Zainuddin, (when he spoke at the opening of the annual
general assembly of the Orang Asli Association of Peninsular Malaysia,
POASM in 1999) that the main reason for Orang Asli poverty is that “they
do not own land” (New Straits Times 10.5.1999).
Without permanent security to their traditional territories, Orang Asli are
reluctant to develop it further. This is best captured in the words of one
Semai headman from Tapah at a dialogue with a former Director-General
of the JHEOA, “Why are you giving us seedlings to grow, when you know
that we will only be growing them for others to enjoy the fruits when they
are mature!”, alluding to the frequent encroachments onto his people’s
lands and the impending threat of his community being asked to resettle
elsewhere.
Without permanent title to their land, Orang Asli are also not able to use
their land as mortgages for bank loans which they may need to expand
their businesses or develop it further. For a long time, even government
ORANG ASLI – RIGHTS, PROBLEMS & SOLUTIONS
39