flexibility, deeper decision-making processes,
and better outcomes for vulnerable people —
including on a systemic level.
A Human Rights Act would provide individuals
with an avenue for recourse to enforce their
rights. This would help to ensure that legislation
applies fairly and inclusively to all.
A Human Rights Act would provide
opportunities for individuals and their advocates
to raise complaints about human rights, to the
Commission and to the courts. The Commission
is a low-cost forum that conciliates complaints.
This means that human rights concerns can
be resolved in a manner that is acceptable
to both parties, without the need to go to
court.116 However, sometimes complaints are not
amenable to conciliation. Access to the courts in
these circumstances is essential.
In a democracy, the judiciary enforces the rule of
law and protect individuals against government
abuses. Parliament makes laws that have general
application, and the courts ensure that specific
applications of the law are fair and just.117 The
judiciary therefore ensures that laws, policies
and decisions do not run roughshod over
people’s rights, even where they do not affect
the majority of the population. A Human Rights
Act would enable courts to consider how human
rights apply in relation to individuals and in
specific circumstances, while maintaining the
intent behind particular laws.
88
Further, when considering how a law applies
in light of the Human Rights Act, courts could
help reveal human rights implications that
were not at first apparent and only emerged
in the application of the law to an individual.
This would give Parliament the opportunity to
reconsider laws in a fresh light. A Human Rights
Act could therefore enhance the ability of
Australia’s democratic institutions to respond to
human rights problems when they do occur.
Indeed, human rights legislation at state and
territory levels and overseas have had tangible
benefits for vulnerable people.118 Julian Gardner
noted that
The protection of rights that a Charter
would afford is particularly important
for those who have less power and are
more vulnerable. For example, in my
former role as Victoria’s Public Advocate
I encountered people with behavioural
issues arising from their disabilities who
were locked up without any power under
relevant legislation to do so and with no
legal oversight. Had the Victorian Charter
been in force this would not have been
allowed.119
The following case studies further illustrate how
Human Rights Acts help to protect the rights of
vulnerable and marginalised people.