The Australian Government’s obligations to
uphold human rights are multi-faceted. It is the
Government’s responsibility to ensure that rights
are respected, protected and fulfilled:
• The obligation to respect human rights
requires that governments, through their
own actions, do not breach human rights.
• The obligation to protect human rights
requires governments to take actions to
prevent others from breaching human
rights. Where a person’s rights have been
breached, the obligation to protect also
requires governments to ensure accessible
and effective remedies are available to that
person.
• The obligation to fulfil human rights
requires governments to take positive
actions to fully realise the equal enjoyment
of human rights.
These different obligations reflect that there
should be a mixture of actions ranging from
legal protections, complaint and compensatory
processes, educational measures, communitybased programs and social services to properly
protect human rights.
Human rights are relevant to all aspects of
government and public life, including all
interactions that public authorities have with
individuals and communities. For example,
they apply when individuals access healthcare,
welfare and education; when individuals are in
prisons, immigration facilities and residential
care homes; and when they engage with police,
child protection and housing authorities.
46
2.2 Patchy human rights
protections
(a) Lack of cohesive human rights
protections
Although Australia has expressed its
commitment to rights and freedoms by ratifying
key international treaties, it has not taken the
step of implementing those obligations fully
into domestic law. Australia has no overarching
Human Rights Act or Constitutional Bill of
Rights, unlike all other liberal democracies.5
This leaves a significant hole in our legal
architecture. The rights that are protected are
located in scattered pieces of legislation, the
Constitution and the common law, forming an
incomplete and piecemeal framework, with
many gaps.
Civil and political rights (as reflected in the
ICCPR) are often taken for granted as given
protections in a democratic society, yet they
cannot always be relied upon by individuals
when they are infringed.
For example, rights to freedom of religion,
privacy and freedom of association are not fully
protected in Australian law.
Australia has also ratified the ICESCR and other
instruments, including the Convention on the
Rights of the Child (CRC) and the Convention on
the Rights of Persons with Disabilities (CRPD),
which contain education, health, equality and
participation rights, among others, that reflect
important Australian values and expectations.
Yet the rights within these instruments are only
reflected in domestic laws to a limited extent,
and related services can be withdrawn at any
time.6