At Chapter 4, we outline how the right to a decent
home, drawing from international human rights
law, Te Tiriti o Waitangi, and these key features
as outlined in the Guidelines, apply in relation to
homelessness and the emergency housing system.
Responding to homelessness and
unmet housing need: the emergency
housing system in Aotearoa New
Zealand
Government policy and responses to homelessness
in Aotearoa New Zealand have evolved over time.
These responses now include both front-line
initiatives that offer immediate support to those
experiencing urgent housing need, and higher-level
policy development of strategies and systems that
seek to combat homelessness.
As homelessness has increased, new policies,
programmes, and funding have been introduced
alongside existing social assistance.7 A range of
programmes and housing support products now
exist:
•
Emergency Housing Special Needs Grant
•
Transitional housing
•
Public housing
•
Accommodation Supplement
•
Temporary Additional Support (where it applies
to accommodation costs).
•
Housing Support Products
Some of these programmes and products are
delivered by the government. Others are delivered
by community providers with funding support
from government. Multiple government agencies
are involved in, and responsible for, the delivery
of both front-line services and strategic policy
development. The Ministry of Social Development
(MSD) and the Ministry of Housing & Urban
Development (HUD) are the main agencies involved
in the design, administration, and delivery of the
emergency housing system.
18
Human Rights Commission
Over the last 12 months, an increasing number
of stories have emerged about problems in
the emergency housing system. We have been
alarmed by the volume and severity of these
issues and worked to hear from those with direct
experience of the system. We have also engaged
with government agencies – both HUD and MSD
– during our Inquiry and have met with a range of
Ministers who hold housing portfolios.
The emergency housing system in Aotearoa
New Zealand is “intended to deliver a range of
outcomes, including access to housing for people
with urgent housing needs, support services, and
a pathway to long-term housing.”8 It currently
involves two separate main initiatives: emergency
accommodation and transitional housing.
1) Emergency Housing Special Needs Grant
(‘housing grant’), which funds non-contracted
temporary emergency accommodation,
2) Transitional housing, delivered by accredited
and contracted housing support providers.
These initiatives together form the bulk of
places in the emergency housing system. A third
initiative within the emergency housing system
involves government-contracted motels providing
emergency housing, including contracted motels
being used during the COVID-19 response and
more recently as a pilot programme in Rotorua.9
In many cases we have heard emergency
accommodation and transitional housing referred
to interchangeably, regardless of whether the
specific housing is emergency accommodation or
transitional housing. However, they are separate
initiatives delivered by different government
agencies and with varying funding models. They
are also significantly different in terms of their
policy intention and the lines of accountability in
each initiative.